Publication
We study the impact of metric constraints on the realizability of planar graphs. Let G be a subgraph of a planar graph H (where H is the "host" of G). The graph G is free in H if for every choice of positive lengths for the edges of G, the host H has a planar straight-line embedding that realizes these lengths; and G is extrinsically free in H if all constraints on the edge lengths of G depend on G only, irrespective of additional edges of the host H. We characterize the planar graphs G that are free in every host H, , and all the planar graphs G that are extrinsically free in every host H, . The case of cycles provides a new version of the celebrated carpenter's rule problem. Even though cycles , , are not extrinsically free in all triangulations, it turns out that "nondegenerate" edge lengths are always realizable, where the edge lengths are considered degenerate if the cycle can be flattened (into a line) in two different ways. Separating triangles, and separating cycles in general, play an important role in our arguments. We show that every star is free in a 4-connected triangulation (which has no separating triangle).