Techno-economic assessment of bioethanol production from lignocellulose by consortium-based consolidated bioprocessing at industrial scale

Lignocellulose-based biofuels are of major importance to mitigate the impact of international traffic and transport on climate change while sustaining agricultural land for food supply. Highly integrated systems like consolidated bioprocessing (CBP), where enzyme production, enzymatic hydrolysis and fermentation of the released sugars are carried out in one reactor, offer the highest potential to save costs and to make lignocellulosebased biofuels economically competitive. The work described here showed that CBP based on a microbial consortium operated at full-scale (2000 t/d) saves up to 27.5 % of the total ethanol production costs compared to conventional ethanol production from lignocellulose in individual process steps. The cost savings are mainly achieved through lower CAPEX due to less apparatus requirements because of the integrated process, as well as through lower OPEX since no glucose is needed for enzyme production. A comparison with literature estimations of cost savings of CBP based on genetically modified microorganisms results in approximately the same range. As a result of a detailed sensitivity analysis, scale and yield were identified as the main cost-pushers from a process point of view, whereas the price level of the plant location has the highest impact on the investment conditions. In the EU, CBP yields enough margin for profitable production and the possibility to decentralize biomass valorization, whereas in the world's largest ethanol market, the U.S, profitable production of lignocellulosic ethanol can only be achieved by CBP combined with other cost saving techniques, such as utilization of cost-free waste feedstocks, since ethanol has undergone a considerable price slump.