Tailoring the Magnetism of Co Atoms on Graphene through Substrate Hybridization

We determine the magnetic properties of individual Co atoms adsorbed on graphene (G) with x-ray absorption spectroscopy and magnetic circular dichroism. The magnetic ground state of Co adatoms strongly depends on the choice of the metal substrate on which graphene is grown. Cobalt atoms on G/Ru(0001) feature exceptionally large orbital and spin moments, as well as an out-of-plane easy axis with large magnetic anisotropy. Conversely, the magnetic moments are strongly reduced for Co/G/Ir(111), and the magnetization is of the easy-plane type. We demonstrate how the Co magnetic properties, which ultimately depend on the degree of hybridization between the Co 3d orbitals and graphene p bands, can be tailored through the strength of the graphene-substrate coupling.

Magnetic properties of surface-adsorbed single rare earth atoms, molecules, and atomic scale clusters

Aparajita Singha

This thesis presents combined experimental and theoretical investigations of nanoscale, surface-supported magnets based on rare earths (RE) to understand and control the magnetic properties down to the scale of single atoms. We present the effects of adatom-substrate interaction on the magnetic properties of isolated single RE atoms using x-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS), x-ray magnetic circular dichroism (XMCD), and multiplet analysis. Our systematic investigations of Dy, Ho, Er, and Tm adatoms adsorbed on Pt(111), Cu(111), Ag(100), and Ag(111), reveal that the REs can possess two types of 4f occupations, namely divalent 4f^n and trivalent 4f^(n-1). The trivalent state is realized in presence of low promotion energy of the RE and strong hybridization of their external spd shell with the surrounding environment. Notably, none of the REs exhibit magnetic hysteresis, suggesting that magnetic relaxation is faster than about 10 seconds. We also report on the effect of adatom-adatom interaction by studying the size-dependent magnetic properties of Er clusters adsorbed on Cu(111). Combining XMCD, scanning tunneling microscopy (STM), and mean-field nucleation theory we reveal that the adatom-adatom interaction dominates over the adatom-substrate interaction in Er clusters starting from the size of three atoms. Consequently the easy axis of Er changes from in-plane for the single atoms and dimers to out-of-plane for trimers and bigger clusters. In addition, the out-of-plane magnetic anisotropy of 2.9 meV/atom results in magnetic hysteresis at 2.5 K in all clusters starting from trimers. With a magnetic lifetime of approximately 2 minutes at 0.1 T, the Er trimers are one of the smallest metal-supported ferromagnetic clusters observed so far. The investigation of adatom-adatom interaction is further extended by studying 4f-3d heterodimers namely, Ho-Co adsorbed on thin insulating layers of MgO. Their magnetic easy axis is oriented out-of-plane. Using spin-polarized STM we have detected spin-excitations in these heterodimers at ±20 and ±8 meV. We have identified the origin behind these spin-excitations using an effective spin Hamiltonian model, which indicates that, given a ferromagnetic exchange interaction between Ho and Co, the most intense feature at ±20 meV corresponds to a transition in which the spin moment of Co is strongly diminished. This is further accompanied by an overall change of the total magnetic moment of the heterodimer, i.e., ¿J=-1. In contrast, the weaker transition at ±8 meV occurs following a change in the out-of-plane moment of Ho while the total moment of the heterodimer remains intact i.e., ¿J=0. Notably, we observe an effective g factor of 3.1 for the ±20 meV transition, which significantly exceeds the free electron value of 2. In addition, the ferromagnetic coupling between Ho and Co is very unusual compared to the ferrimagnetic exchange interaction known for the bulk 4f-3d compounds, especially those derived from the late lanthanides. Nonetheless, this marks the first evidence of spin-excitations in the smallest 4f containing cluster. The knowledge gained on the fundamental aspects of magnetism in surface-supported REs combined with the continued parallel search for magnetic stability down to single atoms, enabled us to achieve magnetic remanence in single adatoms with lifetimes of the order of 1000 s at 2.5 K. In addition we have achieved significantly enhanced hysteresis and magnetic lifetime in TbPc2.

EPFL2017

Magnetism of individual adatoms and of epitaxial monolayers

Anne Lehnert

This thesis reports on the magnetism of low coordinated Fe and Co atoms in different chemical and electronic environments. The objective of this research was to contribute to the fundamental understanding of the magnetic properties, such as magneto-crystalline anisotropy energy (MAE), orbital and spin magnetic moment, of surface supported transition metal (TM) atoms and one atomic layer thick epitaxial TM films. A detailed knowledge on the interplay of electronic hybridization and magnetic properties is mandatory to elaborate new materials with high perpendicular magnetic anisotropy and acceptable writing field for future use in magnetic recording devices. The magnetic properties of the different experimental systems were investigated by x-ray absorption spectroscopy, x-ray magnetic circular dichroism, and magneto-optical Kerr effect (MOKE) and they were correlated to the morphology obtained by scanning tunneling microscopy (STM). The first part focuses on the effect of electronic hybridization between isolated 3d TM atoms and different kinds of substrates. First, we considered 4d and 5d TM substrates known for their high magnetic polarizability due to the close onset of ferromagnetism. Deposition of single Fe and Co atoms on Rh(111), Pd(111), and Pt(111) produces an increasing MAE going from Rh to Pd and finally to Pt that we directly correlate to the increasing spin-orbit constant of the substrate interlinking the induced magnetic moment and the MAE. Further we investigated single Fe and Co atoms on two different insulating layers, namely Al2O3/Ni3Al(111) and Cu2N/Cu(001), providing an efficient decoupling of the TM 3d states from the conduction electrons of the substrates. In case of the alumina film the absorption spectra of Fe and Co show a pronounced multiplet structure. On Cu2N the multiplet features of the adatoms are less defined due to the lower thickness of the screening layer. On both insulating layers we find a common out-of-plane easy axis, highly unquenched orbital moments, and giant MAE values of several meV/atom which are due to the formation of strong anisotropic bonds with the O and N atoms, respectively. The second part is dedicated to single atom thick layers of Fe and Co deposited on Pt(111) and Rh(111). We find the MAE to be strongly enhanced compared with bulk and we establish a direct proportionality between the induced magnetic moment of the topmost substrate layer and the MAE. The study of bimetallic Fe1-xCox alloys on platinum reveal a material with high MAE (0.5 meV at the equiatomic composition), large saturation magnetization (3μB to 2μB going from Fe to Co), and perpendicular magnetization easy axis. These characteristics hint at new possibilities for the further miniaturization of the grain size in recording devices. In the last part the theoretical description of the MOKE for ultra-thin films is extended to the transverse geometry and improved analytic formulae for the polar and longitudinal geometry are presented. This finding was used to optimize the Kerr signal for a new MOKE setup which is fully integrated in an ultrahigh vacuum chamber combining in situ MOKE and STM. The setup performance was demonstrated for a continuous film of 0.9 monolayers (ML) Co/Rh(111) with in-plane easy axis and for a superlattice of nanometric double layer Co islands on Au(11,12,12) with out-of-plane easy axis. The detection limit is 0.5 ML for transverse and 0.1 ML for polar Kerr geometry corresponding for island superlattices with the density of Co/Au(11,12,12) to islands composed of about 50 atoms. Moreover, the setup holds two independent ways to measure the MAE which is either by thermally induced magnetization reversal or by applying a torque onto the magnetization by turning the magnetic field. Both ways yield similar results for 1.1 ML Co/Au(11,12,12).

EPFL2009

Magnetocrystalline anisotropy energy of Co and Fe adatoms on the (111) surfaces of Pd and Rh

Harald Brune, Markus Etzkorn, Pietro Gambardella, Anne Lehnert, Géraud Moulas, Stefano Rusponi

We performed a combined theoretical and experimental investigation of the orbital magnetism and magnetocrystalline anisotropy of isolated Co and Fe adatoms on Pd(111) and Rh(111). Theoretical calculations of the spin and orbital moments are based on ab initio spin-polarized density-functional theory (DFT) including a self-consistent treatment of spin-orbit coupling. The calculations use a slab model to represent the adsorbate/substrate complex and allow for a complete structural relaxation leading to a strong inward displacement of the adatom and modest vertical and lateral relaxations in the substrate atoms. Compared to an idealized geometry where the atoms are kept on bulk lattice positions up to the surface, relaxation leads to a much stronger adatom/ligand hybridization. This is also reflected in the results for orbital moments and magnetocrystalline anisotropy energy (MAE). The enhanced hybridization leads to strong quenching of the adatom orbital moments but also to the formation of large induced spin and orbital moments in the substrate. As a consequence, we find that the substrate contribution to the MAE is much more important than estimated before on the basis of studies using an idealized geometry. We also find the surprising result that the MAE strongly depends on the adsorption site. The magnitude and even the sign of the MAE change for adatoms on face-centered cubic with respect to the ones on hexagonal close-packed hollow sites on the (111) surface. The dependence of the MAE on the combination of adatom and substrate has been analyzed in terms of the electronic structure, leading to a sound physical picture of the origin of the MAE. A fundamental problem, however, is the correct prediction of the size of the orbital moments of the adatoms. We suggest that this problem can be solved only via post-DFT corrections introducing an orbital dependence of the exchange potential. The theoretical results are compared to site-averaged, element-specific x-ray magnetic circular dichroism (XMCD) measurements. Low-temperature XMCD spectra and magnetization curves reveal weak out-of-plane anisotropy for Fe adatoms on both substrates. Interestingly, Co adatoms on Rh(111) present in-plane anisotropy with MAE of about -0.6 meV, contrary to the known out-of-plane anisotropy of Co on Pd(111) and Pt(111). The orbital to spin magnetic-moment ratio measured by XMCD shows that the Co adatoms present much stronger orbital magnetization components compared to Fe. The connection between orbital moments and MAE is discussed at the theoretical level including the contribution of the induced substrate magnetization.

2010