Independent Regulation of Type VI Secretion in Vibrio cholerae by TfoX and TfoY

Type VI secretion systems (T6SSs) are nanomachines used for interbacterial killing and intoxication of eukaryotes. Although Vibrio cholerae is a model organism for structural studies on T6SSs, the underlying regulatory network is less understood. A recent study showed that the T6SS is part of the natural competence regulon in V. cholerae and is activated by the regulator TfoX. Here, we identify the TfoX homolog TfoY as a second activator of the T6SS. Importantly, despite inducing the same T6SS core machinery, the overall regulons differ significantly for TfoX and TfoY. We show that TfoY does not contribute to competence induction. Instead, TfoY drives the production of T6SS-dependent and T6SS-independent toxins, together with an increased motility phenotype. Hence, we conclude that V. cholerae uses its sole T6SS in response to diverse cues and for distinctive outcomes: either to kill for the prey's DNA, leading to horizontal gene transfer, or as part of a defensive escape reaction.

Two nanomachines drive evolution in diverse Vibrio species

Noémie Matthey

Horizontal gene transfer (HGT) has a major impact on bacterial evolution, leading to acquisition or deletion of genes and gene clusters, including those encoding antibiotic resistances and virulence factors. HGT therefore contributes to pathogen emergence, which can have a major impact on human health. As a mode of HGT, natural competence for transformation allows bacteria to directly acquire DNA from the environment and to integrate parts of this genetic material within their genomes. The human pathogen Vibrio cholerae is naturally competent when it grows in association with the chitinous exoskeletons of zooplankton. Under this condition, the competence state is initiated by the regulatory protein TfoX, which co-induces a molecular killing device known as the type VI secretion system (T6SS). The co-regulation of the T6SS and competence results in the lysis of non-immune neighboring bacteria and the subsequent acquisition of their DNA, which fosters HGT. In V. cholerae, the T6SS is also activated by the TfoX homologue protein, named TfoY. In this study, we aimed at studying the regulatory pathways and the co-regulation of interbacterial predation and DNA uptake in order to provide new insights into the environmental lifestyle of V. cholerae and other vibrios. We first investigated the conserved function of TfoX- and TfoY in V. fischeri, V. alginolyticus, and V. parahaemolyticus using diverse methods such as qRT-PCR, interbacterial killing assays, and motility assessments. We demonstrated that TfoX-mediated T6SS and competence induction and TfoY-induced motility are conserved phenotypes in the tested Vibrio species, whereas the TfoY-mediated T6SS regulation varied. These variations might reflect diverse defense mechanisms, as these different species have adapted to cope with their environmental niches. Next, we tested the outcome of the TfoX-mediated co-regulation of the T6SS and competence in V. cholerae. Under conditions mimicking the bacteriumâs natural habitat, we showed for the first time the extent of DNA that was integrated on V. choleraeâs genome after T6SS-mediated interbacterial predation. Indeed, we demonstrated that T6SS-dependent bacterial predation not only increased the transformation rates but also fostered the exchange of multiple and huge fragments of DNA. We also showed the necessity of an exquisite co-regulation between the T6SS, the competence-related DNA uptake machinery, and the competence-repressed nuclease. Finally, we disclosed that prey-released DNA is not a private good of the attacking bacterium but also accessible to other surrounding cells that have likewise entered the competence state. Altogether, our findings shed light on the conservation of the TfoX- and TfoY-driven phenotypes in several Vibrio species. We also contributed to a better understanding of the interplay between neighbor predation and DNA uptake and the consequences that this interplay has on genome plasticity.

EPFL2019

Circulation of a Quorum-Sensing-Impaired Variant of Vibrio cholerae Strain C6706 Masks Important Phenotypes

Melanie Blokesch, Sandrine Stutzmann

Vibrio cholerae, the causative agent of cholera, is a model organism for studying virulence regulation, biofilm formation, horizontal gene transfer, and the cell-to-cell communication known as quorum sensing (QS). As in any research field, discrepancies between data from diverse laboratories are sometimes observed for V. cholerae. Such discrepancies are often caused by the use of diverse patient or environmental isolates. In this study, we investigated the inability of a few laboratories to reproduce high levels of natural transformation, a mode of horizontal gene transfer that is specifically induced on chitinous surfaces. This irreproducibility was mostly related to one specific isolate of V. cholerae: the O1 El Tor C6706 strain. C6706 was previously described as QS proficient, an important prerequisite for the induction of natural competence for transformation. To elucidate the underlying problem, we collected seven isolates of the same C6706 strain from different research laboratories in North America and Europe and compared their phenotypes. Importantly, we observed a split response with respect to QS-related gene expression, including chitin-induced natural competence and type VI secretion (T6S). While approximately half of the strains behaved as reported for several other O1 El Tor pandemic isolates that are commonly studied in the laboratory, the other half were significantly impaired in QS-related expression patterns. This impairment was caused by a mutation in a QS-related gene (luxO). We conclude that the circulation of such QS-impaired wild-type strains is responsible for masking several important phenotypes of V. cholerae, including natural competence for transformation and T6S. IMPORTANCE Phenotypic diversity between laboratory-domesticated bacterial strains is a common problem and often results in the failed reproduction of published data. However, researchers rarely compare such strains to elucidate the underlying mutation(s). In this study, we tested one of the best-studied V. cholerae isolates, O1 El Tor strain C6706 (a patient isolate from Peru), with respect to two main phenotypes: natural competence for transformation and type VI secretion. We recently demonstrated that the two phenotypes are coregulated and specifically induced upon the growth of pandemic V. cholerae O1 El Tor strains on chitinous surfaces. We provide evidence that of seven C6706 strains collected from different laboratories, four were impaired in the tested phenotypes due to a mutation in a QS gene. Collectively, our data indicate that the circulation of such a mutated wild-type strain of C6706 might have had important consequences for QS-related data.

Amer Soc Microbiology2016

Two nanomachines drive evolution in diverse Vibrio species

Noémie Matthey

EPFL2019

Circulation of a Quorum-Sensing-Impaired Variant of Vibrio cholerae Strain C6706 Masks Important Phenotypes

Melanie Blokesch, Sandrine Stutzmann

Amer Soc Microbiology2016