More Medicines for Tuberculosis: Fuelling Drug Discovery against Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Tuberculosis (TB), whose etiological agent is Mycobacterium tuberculosis (M. tuberculosis), has plagued humanity since antiquity. Even with chemotherapy available today, TB is the leading cause of death due to an infectious disease. Modern day factors, such as the HIV epidemic and the emergence of drug-resistant TB strains, have redefined the complexities and challenges of tackling the TB pandemic. Current treatments for TB are lengthy, and poor adherence to such prolonged treatment further exacerbates the issue of drug resistance. Moreover, therapies for drug-resistant TB have low cure rates. There is therefore a pressing need for improved therapies that are short and efficacious against all TB strains, which can be achieved through new antimicrobials that are more potent and have novel mechanisms of action, in addition to being affordable, orally bioavailable, and without drug-drug interactions. Such new anti-TB drugs need to be discovered and developed through a long, risky, and costly process, in which attrition rates are high. While there are promising compounds currently being developed, including the benzothiazinones (BTZs), it is necessary to further populate and enhance the Global TB drug pipeline to ensure the availability of new drugs. This thesis aims to address this need through the discovery work of two new, highly promising families, the AX and PB compounds, and of BTZs. The piperazine-based AX analogs are easily synthesised and demonstrate potent activity against M. tuberculosis in vitro and in vivo. Their target, identified in this work, is the QcrB subunit of the cytochrome bc1-aa3 complex, a terminal oxidase of the mycobacterial respiratory chain. Notably, AX compounds are bactericidal in the absence of the alternate terminal oxidase, cytochrome bd. As this family interacts differently in the same binding site of QcrB as Q203, a drug candidate in clinical trials, AX compounds could potentially serve as a backup series for QcrB inhibitors. The PB family, derived from the natural product lapachol, is also easily synthesised and shows substantially improved activity against M. tuberculosis in vitro compared to the parent compound. PB analogs also demonstrated activity against the non-replicating bacillus and in infected macrophages. The mechanism of action of PB compounds relies on the F420 cofactor, although not on the F420-dependent nitroreductase Ddn, therefore this family has a novel mechanism of action which is highly specific to M. tuberculosis. To support the clinical development of PBTZ169, the mechanism of resistance to BTZs was further elucidated in this thesis. Five mutations at cysteine 387 of the target enzyme, DprE1, were identified as mediating resistance to BTZs, which would serve as resistance markers for clinical screening. The impact of these mutations on M. tuberculosis and on DprE1 was further characterised, revealing a fitness cost imposed on the bacillus intracellularly and reduced catalytic efficiency of the enzyme. This thesis additionally contributed to the characterisation of a PBTZ169 backup series and the design of an optimal regimen with other TB drugs. The compounds presented herein merit further optimisation so their full antibiotic potential may be realised for TB, and possibly for other mycobacterial diseases as well. Altogether, this thesis has contributed to the fuelling of drug discovery against M. tuberculosis, and a step towards more medicines for TB.

Innovative Tools and in vivo Methods for Tuberculosis Drug Discovery and Development

Raphael Christopher Sommer

Worldwide, tuberculosis (TB) is the leading cause of death due to a single infectious agent, claiming 1.6 million human lives and causing >10 million new cases in 2017 alone, mostly in low-income regions. The intracellular pathogen Mycobacterium tuberculosis is the etiological agent and generally infects the lungs. Although treatments exist, curing TB requires long and often expensive chemotherapy, frequently accompanied by undesirable side-effects. In the absence of an effective vaccine and with the increasing emergence of multidrug resistance, new and more powerful antibiotics are urgently needed to control the global TB crisis. In this respect, benzothiazinones (BTZs), a class of new anti-TB compounds, have recently been discovered. Macozinone (PBTZ169), that has reached phase I and II clinical trials in Switzerland and Russia, respectively, is undoubtedly the most promising drug of this category. We derivatized PBTZ169 into a fluorescent chemical probe that efficiently, covalently and selectively labels the enzyme DprE1, thereby localizing the target of BTZs to the periplasm at the poles of actinobacteria. We further discuss the potential applications of such probes for in vivo imaging, mycobacterial detection and designing new diagnostic tools. In general, the search for novel anti-mycobacterial drugs is an extremely long process, delaying the progression of new compounds down the pipeline and to the clinic. Assessing drug efficacy in vivo typically requires extensive resources and is time-consuming. This process can be shortened by applying alternative and innovative methods devised in this thesis, namely the implementation of in vivo imaging procedures and use of the zebrafish embryo model of mycobacterial infection for drug discovery and development. In vivo imaging enables bacterial loads in animal models to be assessed in real time, by means of fluorescence or bioluminescence imaging. We constructed, optimized and characterized genetically engineered near-infrared fluorescent reporters of the pathogens Mycobacterium marinum and M. tuberculosis that allow direct visualization of bacteria in infected zebrafish and mice, respectively. Furthermore, we show that the fluorescence level accurately reflects the bacterial load, as determined by colony forming unit enumeration, thus enabling the efficacy of antibiotic treatment to be assessed in live animals. Alternatively, we applied autobioluminescent M. tuberculosis to evaluate drug efficacy in mice and demonstrated that our system enables the therapeutic response to be followed in real time. Longitudinal imaging also reduces the number animals required thus providing a substantial gain of time and resources. Finally, the zebrafish embryo is an inexpensive and faster alternative model that has been applied to investigate mycobacterial pathogenesis. We implemented this model of M. marinum infection and successfully applied it to assess the activity of several drugs in vivo. Altogether, the innovative methods described in this work are advantageous for TB drug discovery and development, especially for the in vivo evaluation of new anti-mycobacterial candidates, and provide more ethically acceptable approaches and biomedical applications.

EPFL2019

Optimized Background Regimen for Treatment of Active Tuberculosis with the Next-Generation Benzothiazinone Macozinone (PBTZ169)

Stewart Cole, Shi-Yan Caroline Foo, Jean-Yves Gillon, Andréanne Lupien, Anthony Vocat

The efficacy of the standardized four-drug regimen (comprising isoniazid, rifampin, pyrazinamide, and ethambutol) for the treatment of tuberculosis (TB) is menaced by the emergence of multidrug-resistant (MDR) and extensively drugresistant (XDR) strains of Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Intensive efforts have been made to develop new antibiotics or to repurpose old drugs, and several of these are currently being evaluated in clinical trials for their antitubercular activity. Among the new candidate drugs is macozinone (MCZ), the piperazine-containing benzothiazinone PBTZ169, which is currently being evaluated in phase I/II clinical trials. Here, we determined the in vitro and in vivo activity of MCZ in combination with a range of anti-TB drugs in order to design a new regimen against active TB. Two-drug combinations with MCZ were tested against M. tuberculosis using checkerboard and CFU enumeration after drug exposure assays. MCZ was observed to have no interactions with all first- and second-line anti-TB drugs. At the MIC of each drug, MCZ with either bedaquiline (BDQ), clofazimine (CLO), delamanid (DMD), or sutezolid (STZ) reduced the bacterial burden by 2 logs compared to that achieved with the drugs alone, indicating synergism. MCZ also displayed synergism with clomiphene (CLM), a potential inhibitor of the undecaprenyl pyrophosphate synthase (UppS) in mycobacteria. For all the other drugs tested in combination with MCZ, no synergistic activity was observed. Neither antagonism nor increased cytotoxicity was found for most combinations, suggesting that MCZ could be added to different TB treatment regimens without any significant adverse effects.

AMER SOC MICROBIOLOGY2018

Towards a new tuberculosis drug: pyridomycin - nature's isoniazid

Stewart Cole, Joao Pedro De Almeida Neres, Ruben Hartkoorn, Sophie Magnet, Raju Mukherjee, Florence Pojer, Claudia Sala, Swapna Uplekar

Tuberculosis, a global threat to public health, is becoming untreatable due to widespread drug resistance to frontline drugs such as the InhA-inhibitor isoniazid. Historically, by inhibiting highly vulnerable targets, natural products have been an important source of antibiotics including potent anti-tuberculosis agents. Here, we describe pyridomycin, a compound produced by Dactylosporangium fulvum with specific cidal activity against mycobacteria. By selecting pyridomycin-resistant mutants of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, whole-genome sequencing and genetic validation, we identified the NADH-dependent enoyl(Acyl-Carrier-Protein) reductase InhA as the principal target and demonstrate that pyridomycin inhibits mycolic acid synthesis in M. tuberculosis. Furthermore, biochemical and structural studies show that pyridomycin inhibits InhA directly as a competitive inhibitor of the NADH-binding site, thereby identifying a new, druggable pocket in InhA. Importantly, the most frequently encountered isoniazid-resistant clinical isolates remain fully susceptible to pyridomycin, thus opening new avenues for drug development.

Wiley Open Access2012

Innovative Tools and in vivo Methods for Tuberculosis Drug Discovery and Development

Raphael Christopher Sommer

EPFL2019