Seismic performance of slender RC U-shaped walls with a single-layer of reinforcement

Katrin Beyer, Ryan Hoult, João Saraiva Esteves Pacheco de Almeida
2020
Journal paper

Abstract

Reinforced concrete walls are commonly used to resist the lateral loading induced by wind and earthquake actions. While most walls include two vertical reinforcement layers, some regions of the world construct slender, non-rectangular concrete walls with a single vertical layer of reinforcement. The seismic performance of such elements is largely unknown given the paucity of experimental research. This paper presents the results of two slender reinforced concrete U-shaped walls tested at the Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics Laboratory (EESD Lab), École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL) in Switzerland. Both wall specimens, designed similar to construction practice in Colombia, were tested using quasi-static cyclic loading to observe if out-of-plane instability would develop when deformations were limited to prevent the flange boundary ends crushing. Initial failure of both wall specimens corresponded with local out-of-plane buckling in the boundary ends of the flanges occurring on load reversal. The buckling lengths were approximately 700–800 mm, which corresponded to 44–50 bar diameters. The crack patterns were observed to be steepest in the web of the walls, demonstrating the increased shear demand in comparison to that of a rectangular wall. Both wall specimens reached ultimate drifts larger than 2.5–3.0% before global failure occurring in the web-flange intersection due to crushing. A small twist was subjected to one of the walls when centered and loaded diagonally, which showed that the decay in torsional stiffness is proportional to the decay in translational stiffness.

Official source

https://infoscience.epfl.ch/record/281129?ln=en

About this result

This page is automatically generated and may contain information that is not correct, complete, up-to-date, or relevant to your search query. The same applies to every other page on this website. Please make sure to verify the information with EPFL's official sources.

Related concepts

Related publications

Katrin Beyer, Ryan Hoult, João Saraiva Esteves Pacheco de Almeida
2020
Journal paper

Abstract

Official source

https://infoscience.epfl.ch/record/281129?ln=en

About this result

Related concepts (14)

Related concepts

Related publications (25)

Related publications

The Deformation Capacity of Lap Splices in RC Walls: From Experimental Testing to Numerical Modelling

Danilo Tarquini

Field observations as well as experimental tests have shown that both the strength and displacement capacity of reinforced concrete (RC) members might be significantly reduced by the presence of lap splices. This degradation applies in particular if the longitudinal reinforcement is spliced in regions where inelastic deformations concentrate, which is frequently the case for RC building walls or bridge piers. In fact, these members often feature lap splices above the foundation level, where seismic demands are largest and damage is likely to occur. In performance-based earthquake engineering (PBEE), which now sets the standards for seismic assessment, deformation rather than force capacities are compared to the demand; however, past experimental studies on spliced members have focused on the characterization of the strength rather than the deformation capacity of lap splices. Further-more, these tests were primarily performed on spliced RC beam and column specimens, typically subjected to mono-tonic loading. Experimental investigations on the deformation capacity of members with lap splices under cyclic loading are underrepresented. This applies in particular to walls, despite the fact that splicing of longitudinal reinforcement in their plastic hinge regions is common construction practice. In line with the available experimental work, most of the developed empirical and analytical expressions aim solely at quantifying the force capacity of lap splices. The preceding observations have motivated the following objectives of the present work: (i) investigate the displacement capacity of spliced RC walls through experimental tests; (ii) propose expressions characterizing the deformation capacity of lap splices subjected to monotonic and cyclic loading; and (iii) develop numerical and mechanical models suitable for practicing engineers to simulate the behaviour of RC members with lap splices. Existing experimental programmes on spliced RC walls, including the cyclic test of two units recently carried out at the structural laboratory of EPFL, are first reviewed and collected in a database. The review of the experimental data shows that the failure of the outermost lap splices, located in the boundary element, typically triggers the failure of the RC wall. Moreover, the main parameters influencing the deformation capacity of lap splices are identified. Building on these findings, an experimental programme on spliced RC wall boundary elements is designed using lapsplice length, confining reinforcement, and loading history as variable parameters. From the obtained results, an empirical expression for the lap-splice strain capacity is derived. A 2D shell element model is first developed to simulate the global force-displacement response of the walls in the aforementioned database. The lap splice response is considered through a new equivalent uniaxial steel stress-strain law. Secondly, an axially equilibrated displacement-based beam element model is proposed in which the lap splice response can be included by using the derived strain limit expression. Finally, a novel mechanical model describing the behaviour of spliced RC wall boundary elements is presented. It extends the tension chord model by accounting for anchorage slip and the presence of lap splices.

EPFL2019

Out of plane instability of reinforced concrete walls is a failure mechanism observed rather recently following the earthquakes in Chile (2010) and New Zealand (2011). Global out of plane instability is a phenomenon that may occur in thin walls, subjected to in plane cyclic loading, which develop large out of plane deformations over the storey height. Past experimental efforts to study this phenomenon focussed on thin members with two layers of longitudinal reinforcement. Hence, also the phenomenological models proposed in literature were mainly based on experimental evidence from double layered members. However, a constructive boom in Latin America, together with an elevated cost of materials, has led over the last fifteen years to the massive construction of reinforced concrete buildings in which the shear walls are very thin and have a single layer of reinforcement. Given the lack of experimental data on single layered members made it questionable whether the mechanism develops as in double layered members, and if the existing models are capable to reproduce the response. In view of the above, the present thesis has the two following goals: (i) Provide new experimental insight on the out of plane instability of members with a single layer of reinforcement; (ii) Develop and validate numerical and mechanical tools to simulate and assess the vulnerability of thin walls to out of plane buckling. The experimental findings obtained from two experimental programs, on thin walls and isolated wall boundary elements respectively, are presented. The importance of the maximum (or critical) tensile strain experienced by the member to trigger instability, which was already identified in the past, is supported by the experimental results. Nevertheless, discrepancies from the usual hypotheses assumed for members with two layers of reinforcement are pinpointed, in particular with respect to the buckling height involved in the deformation, and to the magnitude of the axial force at onset of out of plane instability. Moreover, the crucial role played by the crack pattern is discussed, and an innovative failure criteria based on a three hinge mechanism related to the compressive strains attained in the cracks is identified. Finally, also the adverse effect of an imposed out of plane displacement at the top is also addressed. For a more thorough understanding of the phenomenon, and with the intent of developing simple methods to calculate the critical tensile strain triggering out of plane failure, numerical models are developed and validated against experimental results. The simulations allowed identifying important differences between the isolated boundary element and the wall behaviour, in particular with respect to the vertical displacement profile along the height. On the basis of the numerical findings, an improved boundary element model, rather simple to use for assessment and design, is presented. Finally, building on the experimental and numerical findings, a new mechanical is proposed. The model is in principle developed for members with one layer of reinforcement, but it is shown how it can be extended to double layered members. The mechanical model sets apart from existing ones as it assumes different curvature and vertical displacement profiles along the entire storey height, it accounts for axial forces lower than yielding in compression, and it allows to consider various boundary conditions.

EPFL2018

Welded moment connections with highly dissipative panel zones for enhanced seismic performance of steel moment frames

Andronikos Skiadopoulos

Research conducted after the 1994 Northridge earthquake in the U.S. and the 1995 Kobe earthquake in Japan led to the development of today's pre-qualified beam-to-column connections for capacity-designed steel moment resisting frames (MRFs). Welded moment connections feature weld backing bars that should be removed after the execution of complete joint penetration groove welds at the bottom beam flange-to-column flange joint. On the other hand, advancements in steel and weld materials, as well as fabrication techniques, allow for the exploitation of simplified weld details at this location. In welded moment connections for seismic applications, the participation of the beam-to-column web panel zones in the energy dissipation is generally limited during an earthquake event. In such a design context, beam local buckling is likely even at modest lateral drift demands, thereby engendering structural repair costs in the aftermath of earthquakes. The primary reasons for such a seismic design practice are twofold. The first one relates to known limitations of panel zone design models that compromise our ability to effectively balance the seismic design of fully restrained beam-to-column connections. The second one relates to the panel zone kinking that could increase the fracture potential of beam-to-column connections. However, recent experiments in the literature provide controversial results regarding the same matter.This doctoral thesis aims at advancing the state-of-knowledge regarding the seismic design and behavior of steel MRFs with highly dissipative panel zones. A new panel zone design model was first developed. This model addresses the limitations of all available panel zone models in the literature. The model was validated thoroughly with about 100 available experiments that encompass a broad range of geometric parameters. The panel zone model can effectively enable a balanced seismic design of welded moment connections with inelastic panel zones. One step further, this thesis revisited the current detailing of welded connections. Simplifications in their fabrication process were proposed by intentionally keeping a customized beveled backing bar in place, without impairing the connection's ductility under cyclic loading. The proposed connection weld detail is substantiated by continuum finite element analyses and full-scale experiments on welded moment connections with highly dissipative panel zones. It is demonstrated that, contrary to the current design paradigm, a stable hysteretic response is achieved up until lateral drift demands of at least 7% rad, thereby diminishing the cyclic deterioration in story shear resistance. As such, the seismic stability of steel MRFs is only governed by global P-Delta effects. Quantitative seismic response characteristics of steel MRFs with highly dissipative panel zones through large-scale systel-level parametric studies were also provided. It is shown that steel MRFs with highly inelastic panel zones, have up to two times lower mean annual frequency of collapse than corresponding results with steel MRFs designed with the current status quo. It is also demonstrated that steel MRFs with inelastic panel zones, enjoy up to 50% reduction in residual story drift ratios at a design-basis earthquake; their beam-to-column connections do not experience fractures due to panel zone kinking; and local buckling in steel beams is very limited even at low probability of occurrence seismic events.

EPFL2022