Stability and physical properties of alkylsilane and alkylphosphonate self-assembled monolayer (SAM) films on metal oxide substrates characterized at the micro- and nanoscale

Self-assembled monolayer (SAM) films have attracted immense attention for both fundamental and applied research. A SAM is composed of a large number of molecules with a head group that chemisorbs onto a substrate, a tail group that interacts with the outer surface of the film, and a spacer (backbone) chain group that connects the head and tail groups resulting in a coating. Interactions between spacer groups of different molecules, such as van der Waals forces and/or hydrogen bonding, hasten SAM film formation and contribute to its stability. In this dissertation, SAM and thin films have been formed onto copper and aluminum oxide surfaces by reaction with 1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluorodecyldimethylchlorosilane (PFMS), 1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluorodecyltrichlorosilane (PFTS), 1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluorodecylphosphonic acid (PFDP), octylphosphonic acid (OP), decylphosphonic acid (DP), and octadecylphosphonic acid (ODP). The properties and stability of the films were investigated employing complementary surface analysis techniques: X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), atomic force microscopy (AFM), friction force microscopy (FFM), a derivative of AFM, contact angle measurements (CAMs), and Fourier transform infrared reflection/absorption spectroscopy (FT-IRRAS). The perfluoroalkylsilane SAM on Cu is found to be extremely hydrophobic typically having sessile drop static contact angles of more than 130° for pure water and a surface energy of 14 mJ/m2 (mN/m). FFM showed a significant reduction in the adhesive force and friction coefficient of PFMS modified Cu (PFMS/Cu) compared to unmodified Cu. Treatment by exposure to harsh conditions showed that PFMS/Cu SAM can withstand boiling nitric acid (pH=1.8), boiling water, and warm sodium hydroxide (pH=12, 60 °C) solutions for at least 30 minutes. Furthermore, no SAM degradation was observed when PFMS/Cu was exposed to warm nitric acid solution for up to 70 min at 60 °C or 50 min at 80 °C. XPS and FT-IRRAS data reveal a coordination of the PFMS silicon (Si) atom with a cuprate (CuO) molecule present on the oxidized copper substrate. The data give good evidence that the stability of the SAM film on the PFMS modified oxidized Cu surface is largely due to the formation of a siloxy-copper (-Si-O-Cu-) bond via a condensation reaction between silanol (-Si-OH) and copper hydroxide (CuOH). For a PFTS modified Cu surface (PFTS/Cu), the sessile drop static contact angle of pure water has been measured to be more than 125° and the surface energy to be typically less than 16 mJ/m2. Stability tests show that the PFTS/Cu film can survive in boiling pure water for one hour, boiling nitric acid (pH 1.5 or 1.8) for 30 minutes, sodium hydroxide solution (pH 12, 70 °C) for 30 minutes, and autoclave conditions (steam at 134 °C and 3 atmospheres) for 15 minutes. The more commonly used self-assembled monolayer (SAM) modifications of Cu surfaces, e.g. thiol compounds, are significantly less stable than PFTS/Cu. Extremely hydrophobic (low surface energy) and stable PFMS/Cu SAMs and PFTS/Cu films could be useful as corrosion inhibitors in micro/nanoelectronic devices and/or as promoters for anti-wetting, low adhesion surfaces or drop-wise condensation on heat exchange surfaces. XPS analysis confirmed the presence of perfluorinated and non-perfluorinated alkylphosphonate molecules on the PFDP, DP, and ODP SAMs deposited at the aluminum oxide coated silicon (Al/Si) surfaces. The sessile drop static contact angle of pure water on PFDP SAMs was typically more than 130° and on DP and ODP typically more than 125° indicating that the phosphonic acid SAMs reacted with Al samples were very hydrophobic. The surface roughness for PFDP/Al, DP/Al, ODP/Al, and bare Al was approximately 35 nm, as determined by AFM. The surface energy for PFDP/Al was determined to be approximately 11 mJ/m2 by the Zisman plot method compared to 21 mJ/m2 and 20 mJ/m2 for DP/Al and ODP/Al, respectively. PFDP/Al gave the lowest adhesion and friction force while bare Al gave the highest. The adhesion and friction forces for ODP/Al and DP/Al SAMs were in between. ODP, DP, and OP SAMs have been studied in detail on relatively flat aluminum oxide surfaces. The rms surface roughness for ODP/Al, DP/Al, OP/Al, and bare Al was less than 15 nm, as determined by AFM. The sessile drop static contact angle of pure water on ODP/Al and DP/Al was typically more than 115° and on OP/Al typically less than 105°. The surface energy for ODP/Al and DP/Al was determined to be approximately 21 mJ/m2 and 22 mJ/m2, respectively, compared to 26 mJ/m2 for OP/Al. ODP/Al and OP/Al were studied by FFM to better understand their micro-/nano-tribological properties. ODP/Al gave the lowest coefficient of friction values while bare Al gave the highest. The adhesion forces for ODP/Al and OP/Al were comparable. The chemical stability of ODP/Al, PFDP/Al, DP/Al, OP/Al, and PFMS/Al SAMs has been inspected by exposure to warm nitric acid (pH 1.8, 30 min, 60-95 °C). The XPS data and stability against harsh chemical conditions indicate that a type of bond forms between a phosphonic acid (PA) or silane molecule and the oxidized Al surface. Stability tests using warm nitric acid (pH 1.8, 30 min, 60-95 °C) show ODP/Al SAMs to be most stable followed by PFDP/Al, DP/Al, PFMS/Al, and OP/Al SAMs. For PFTS/Al, stability tests demonstrate that modified aluminum is able to survive exposure to warm nitric acid (pH = 1.8, 60 °C, 30 min) indicating some degree of robustness. Hydrophobic, low adhesion, and robust aluminum surfaces have useful applications for micro/nano-electromechanical systems (MEMS/NEMS), such as digital micro-mirror devices (DMDs). These studies are expected to aid in the design and selection of proper lubricants for MEMS/NEMS.

Supramolecular structures of polypeptides

Daniela Silvano

The formation of supramolecular structures is a central issue in bio- and nanotechnology and therein plays an important role for many novel developments such as biocompatible materials for integrating living cells or coating for implantable sensing devices as well as for designing smart molecular sensor surfaces for miniaturized bioanalytical techniques. The main focus of this thesis is the investigation of polypeptide layers on surfaces, in particular the formation of self-assembled monolayers (SAMs). SAMs made of long hydrocarbon chains or aromatic molecules comprising surface active and other functional groups have been deeply characterized over decades. Surprisingly, peptide SAMs did not meet the same strong interest despite their great potential in several areas. Natural (20) and artificial amino acids with different physical and chemical properties offer a plethora of novel possibilities to design coating of solid surfaces. In fact their combination in simple oligopeptide sequences provides a huge number of molecular components for the formation of SAMs. Control of SAM features such as density, flexibility, adaptability, interface properties, by tailoring the amino acid sequence opens a new route to manifold applications ranging from fundamental research to nano- and biotechnology. In this thesis different and complementary techniques have been used to investigate the self-assembling ability of polypeptides on surfaces with different physical and chemical properties. Infrared spectroscopy and circular dichroism allowed the determination of the peptide secondary structure on surfaces and in solution. Surface plasmon resonance provided the optical thicknesses of peptide SAMs on gold whereas contact angle measurements have been used to characterize their interfacial properties. In the first part of the thesis, a series of hydrophobic peptides (Ac-Cys-Alax-CONH2, x=3-6) have been self assembled on gold via the thiol group present in the cysteine. The main interest was whether these peptides formed densely packed SAMs with a defined secondary structure within the layer and how the properties of such SAMs depended on the length of the polypeptide backbone. The second part concerns the study of the interactions of an amphipathic helical peptide with various functionalized substrates. The aim was to investigate whether a proper design of the peptide could be used to predetermine its secondary structure on the substrate and whether the orientation of the peptide on the surface could be directly controlled via certain parameters of the surrounding medium. Since the hydrophilic residues of the peptide are histidines, a particular effort was spent in characterizing the peptide adsorption on substrates exposing nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA) moieties. Once established that the adsorption process did not alter its helical structure, the peptide was adsorbed on a substrate exposing two different functional groups: NTA, that could interact with the histidine residues, and methyl groups, that could interact with the hydrophobic ones. The goal was to bind the peptide in different orientation to the same substrate, exploiting the particular spatial distribution of its residues. The third part of this thesis concern the formation of nano- and micro-sized fibrils through molecular self-assembly of simple oligopeptides and protected amino acids. Such systems were chosen as models to investigate the role of the different driving forces in the formation of fibrillar structures. The aromatic protecting group being fixed, it could be shown that the protected amino acids formed fibrils with different sizes and morphologies, or did not form fibrils at all, depending on how strongly their side chains interact. The possibility of forming fibrils by using protected amino acids is of major importance not only in bio-related field but also in organic nanotechnology.

EPFL2008

Wetting properties of flat-top periodically structured superhydrophobic surfaces

Laura Barbieri

In recent years, superhydrophobic surfaces have attracted a considerable amount of attention from the academic and industrial communities. This growing interest is mainly caused by the fundamental physico-chemical theoretical aspects that remain obscure and the number of promising practical applications emerging in a wide range of fields, such as textiles, self-cleaning coatings, and micro-fluidic systems. Superhydrophobic surfaces exhibit simultaneously high static water contact angles and low resistance to liquid motion on the surface (i.e. low contact angle hysteresis). These properties result from the combination of the chemical hydrophobicity of the topmost layers of the surface and its roughness, the latter being the dominant factor. In this PhD work, advantage has been taken of recent advances in micro-/nano-processing technologies to fabricate microstructured surfaces with specific and controlled roughness. This has enabled systematic experimental investigations to be carried out to address some of the still unanswered questions relating to superhydrophobic phenomena. Silicon wafers were microstructured by photolithography in order to obtain periodical distributions of well-defined flat-top obstacles. A gas-phase silanization process was used to cover the prepared microstructured surfaces with a hydrophobic dense mono-layer of perfluorodecyltrichlorosilane. Several series of samples in which each roughness parameter (distance between obstacles, obstacle height, obstacle size, obstacle shape, etc.) was individually varied were fabricated, and static and dynamic contact angle variations as a function of each parameter were studied. The results obtained by water contact angle measurements were compared to the classic Wenzel and Cassie models. The first assumes that the liquid wets the asperities of the rough substrate completely (referred to as wetted state), whilst the second describes the liquid as sitting on a mixture of air and solid (referred to as composite state). By systematically varying a given parameter, a transition between the composite and the wetted regime was observed. Simple thermodynamic considerations based on the energy minimization of the drop-substrate system showed that Cassie and Wenzel contact angles correspond to two energy minima of the system. Experimentally, the Cassie regime is observed when the Cassie angle is the absolute energy minimum, while when the Wenzel angle is the absolute energy minimum, either the Wenzel regime or a metastable Cassie state is observed. The existence of these metastable states is explained theoretically by the energy barrier that the system has to overcome to reach the Wenzel state when a drop is gently deposited on the surface, and good agreement with experimental data is demonstrated. Water and n-hexadecane dynamic contact angle measurements performed in two different configurations, i.e. with a "negligible" and a "NON-negligible" extra-pressure exerted on the drop-substrate system, permitted the validity of the theoretical model proposed to be confirmed. They clearly evidenced the region of stability of both Wenzel and Cassie regimes, and particularly the region where the Cassie regime is metastable, which is the really interesting one for all the potential applications of rough superhydrophobic surfaces as self-cleaning, and non-sticking surfaces, since only the metastable composite states are those characterized by a very high contact angle and a very low contact angle hysteresis, the two main requirements for a good superhydrophobic surface. With systematic reduction of the absolute size of the obstacles in the micrometer range, an increase in the extent and robustness of the composite states was observed. Drop contact line fragmentation seems to be the most important factor in determining the extent and robustness of the observed composite states. Results obtained by varying the obstacle top-surface shape demonstrate that contact line length and corrugations are only secondary factors. Studies on the influence of asperity absolute size performed in the micrometer range, together with preliminary but fundamental results obtained on nanostructured substrates, allow the proposal of interesting conclusions concerning determination of roughness size where macroscopic superhydrophobicity appears and vanishes. A typical size of ∼ 50 µm (where "typical size" refers to the width of the obstacle top-surface) can be considered the upper limit of the superhydrophobicity scale range, with a length scale of some tens of nanometers as the lower limit. In this range, the length scale comprised between several hundred nanometers and one micrometer can be assumed the most suitable size for obtaining superhydrophobic properties of larger extent and robustness. The related appropriate asperity height must be sufficiently great to prevent the drop meniscus from touching the bottom of the asperities by vibration, inducing a transition to the wetted Wenzel state.

EPFL2007

Single-molecule-level characterization of supramolecular systems at surfaces

Dietmar Payer

This thesis deals with the self-organization of individual building blocks, specifically organic molecules and metal atoms, into supramolecular structures on metal surfaces under ultra high vacuum conditions (UHV). Self-organization of supramolecular systems is a promising candidate for a bottom-up approach in the fabrication of complex structures with specific properties. This process is steered by interactions between functional groups of the individual building blocks and is of apparent interest to gain a detailed understanding of the influence and the behavior of these functional groups enabling intermolecular binding. In the first part of the thesis, we investigate hydrogen bonded structures on metal surfaces. Of especial interest is the possibility of the formation of ionic hydrogen bonds, a special class of hydrogen bond which connects a charged donor (acceptor) and a neutral acceptor (donor) and is important in biological systems. By combined Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM), X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) and Near Edge X-ray Absorption Fine Structure (NEXAFS) measurement we show the deprotonation of carboxylic functions in the molecules, forming carboxylate groups involved in intermolecular binding. With our complementary experimental and theoretical examinations we clearly show that the carboxylate groups are indeed still charged although adsorbed onto a conducting metal surface and that the observed structures can be computationally reproduced by using these charges in classical molecular dynamic calculations. Our investigations clearly reveal that all requirements for the formation of ionic hydrogen bonds in these samples at metal surfaces under solvent free conditions are fulfilled. In the second part, the confinement of surface state electrons in self-assembled hydrogen-bonded structures is investigated. The examined structure contains two-dimensional cavities, with different inner diameters in the periodic arrangement and in domain boundaries. Inside the cavities we detect a spatially localized modification in the local density of states (LDOS) of the Ag(111) surface state electrons. The energy of the peak correlates with the cavity area as predicted by a simple "particle in a box" model. This clearly shows that the surface state electrons form a confined state inside the cavities. Furthermore we examine self-assembled periodic structures as templates for binding single macrocyclic molecules. The macrocyclic molecules can be deposited by sublimation, as STM-topographs with submolecular resolution reflect the shape of the intact molecules and reveal a coverage dependent aggregation behavior. We show that it is possible to fabricate a structure in which at most one macrocyclic molecule per pore can be found in a defined binding position. In the last part of the thesis we investigate the influence of individual metal atoms on the chemical activity and the self-assembly process of molecules on metal surfaces. First, we demonstrate the high chemical reactivity of these metal atoms. In our experiments we address the chemical reactivity of static active sites, like kinks and step edges, and of dynamic active sites, like the metal atoms, separately. Doing this we show that a non-negligible amount of the chemical reactivity of a metal surface is due to this dynamic adatom gas. Furthermore the influence of metal atoms on the structure formation of organic molecules is investigated. We show that two-dimensional structures based on a complex formation between metal centers and ligands can be formed and that the coordination number is independent of the substrate symmetry. Furthermore, we show the possibility that on metal surfaces one can prepare three-fold coordinated Fe-centers, a coordination number which is rarely seen in three dimensional chemistry. In the last part we study catenanes, which consist of two interlocked macrocyclic molecules. Main interest is on the confirmation of a structural change of the catenanes adsorbed on a metal substrate. For our experiments we use the fact that the catenanes are designed to "trap" a Cu-atom by complex formation. As this reaction is associated with a structural change and a change in intermolecular interaction, we can verify a reaction of catenanes adsorbed onto a surface with Cu adatoms and therefore a structural alteration by simply imaging the formed structures. Our measurements show the possibility of depositing large molecules like catenanes by sublimation and of their potential for use as molecular machines adsorbed onto metal surfaces.

EPFL2007

Supramolecular structures of polypeptides

Daniela Silvano

EPFL2008

Wetting properties of flat-top periodically structured superhydrophobic surfaces

Laura Barbieri

EPFL2007

Single-molecule-level characterization of supramolecular systems at surfaces

Dietmar Payer

EPFL2007