Precise measurements of time delays in gravitationally lensed quasars for competitive and independent determination of the Hubble constant

During these last decades, by virtue of observations, the Standard Cosmological Model has emerged, providing a description of the Universe's evolution using a minimal set of independent constraints - the cosmological parameters. Among them is the expansion rate of the Universe, the so-called Hubble constant or H0, first measured by Lemaître in 1927. The century that followed this cornerstone measurement saw numerous attempts to refine the initial value, and for good reason: a precise and independent measurement of H0 will bring strong constraints on the cosmological models. It could notably help the astronomers to better understand the nature of dark energy, thus making it one of the most sought-after prizes in modern cosmology. My work at the Laboratory of Astrophysics of EPFL is embedded in this context. I am part of the COSMOGRAIL and H0LiCOW collaborations, aiming to measure the Hubble constant with the highest level of precision using time-delay cosmography, a method based on the theory of strong gravitational lensing. This effect occurs when an observer looks at a light source located behind a massive foreground galaxy. The mass of the galaxy acts similarly to an optical lens and focuses the light rays emitted by the source. As a consequence, multiple lensed images of the source appear around the lens galaxy. If the luminosity of the source changes over time, the variations will be seen in all the lensed images but with a temporal delay due to the different travel paths of the light rays. By carefully monitoring the luminosity variations of each lensed image, one can precisely measure the temporal delays between them. Combined to high-resolution observations of the foreground galaxy and its surroundings, it is possible to directly measure the Hubble constant upon the sole assumption that the General Relativity is correct. Since more than 13 years, COSMOGRAIL monitors dozens of lensed quasars to produce high-quality light curves and time-delay measurements. During these last four years, I took care of the monitoring schedule, continuous data reduction and time-delay measurements through the development of curve-shifting techniques. I produced light curves and measured time delays on a variety of lenses. After more than a decade of endeavours, COSMOGRAIL and H0LiCOW finally revealed their measurement of the expansion rate of the Universe from a blind analysis of three lensed sources. I had the privilege to be the lead author of the publication presenting our measurement of the Hubble constant, H0=71.9 -3.0+2.4 km/s/Mpc 3.8% precision in the Standard Cosmological Model. Such a precision allows a direct comparison with the results of the distance ladder technique in the local Universe and the Planck satellite Cosmic Microwave Background observations in the distant Universe, both of which being currently in a significant tension of unknown source.

H0LiCOW-I. H-0 Lenses in COSMOGRAIL's Wellspring: program overview

Vivien François Bonvin, Frédéric Courbin, Georges Meylan, Malte Tewes, Olga Tihhonova

Strong gravitational lens systems with time delays between the multiple images allow measurements of time-delay distances, which are primarily sensitive to the Hubble constant that is key to probing dark energy, neutrino physics and the spatial curvature of the Universe, as well as discovering new physics. We present H0LiCOW (H-0 Lenses in COSMOGRAIL's Wellspring), a program that aims to measure H-0 with

Oxford Univ Press2017

Gravitational lenses

Christel Vuissoz

The Hubble constant H0 is one of the most important parameters in cosmology, as it encodes the age of the Universe and is necessary for any distance determination at a cosmological scale. It is, however, only poorly constrained by traditional methods. The current favored value, H0 = 72±8 km s-1 Mpc-1, is provided by the HST Hubble constant Key Project (Freedman et al. 2001), which combines several Cepheid-calibrated distance indicators. This roughly 10% error nevertheless denotes only the statistical uncertainty in the determination of H0, while the possible systematical errors in the first step of the distance ladder (the distance to the Large Magellanic Cloud) may be of the same order of magnitude. Time delays between gravitationally lensed images of distant quasars can yield a more precise measurement of the Hubble constant, on a truly cosmic scale, and independently of any local distance calibrator. At the beginning of this thesis, time delays had been measured in only ten lensed systems, nine of which gave H0 estimates. However before 2004, no concerted and long term action has succeeded to apply the time delay method at a level of precision really competitive with other techniques. The major difficulties arise from the modeling of the lens mass distribution, and from the uncertainty on the time delay measurement itself, which was typically of about 10% in past monitoring programs. COSMOGRAIL (COSmological MOnitoring of GRAvItational Lenses) is an international collaboration initiated in April 2004 at the Laboratory of Astrophysics of EPFL, and which aims at measuring precise time delays for most known lensed quasars, in order to determine the Hubble constant down to an uncertainty of a few percent. This thesis took place at the beginning of COSMOGRAIL and consisted in setting up this large photometric monitoring. It addressed both issues of carrying out accurate photometry of faint blended sources and of obtaining well sampled light curves, in order to measure precise time delays. As part of the COSMOGRAIL project, I have been managing the monitoring of over twenty gravitationally lensed quasars with the 1-2m telescopes involved both in the Northern and Southern hemispheres, and organizing the data. The first crucial work of this thesis was then to develop an automated reduction pipeline able to produce an homogeneous data set from images acquired with very different telescopes. This pipeline was also needed to perform aperture photometry of all lensed quasars, in order to study their variability and define the monitoring priorities. The powerful MCS deconvolution algorithm (Magain, Courbin, & Sohy 1998) was greatly used in this work and allowed to highly improve the image resolution, with the aim of obtaining accurate photometric measurements of the individual quasar lensed images. I have finally tested and improved three different numerical techniques to determine time delays between the quasar components from their light curves. In this thesis, time delays have been determined in four systems. The first one was measured in the doubly imaged quasar SDSS J1650+4251, after two years of monitoring with the 1.5m telescope of Maidanak Observatory, in Uzbekistan. The quadruply lensed system RXS J1131–1231 was then studied and three time delays determined from 3-year observations with the Swiss Euler 1.2m telescope located at La Silla, in Chile. The photometric monitoring of the quadruple WFI J2033–4723 was also carried out with the Euler telescope, and data were then merged with those obtained by a second monitoring group, with the SMARTS 1.3m telescope at the Cerro Tololo Interamerican Observatory (CTIO), also located in Chile. Two time delays were measured in this system, after three years of observations, the close pair A1 – A2 remaining unresolved. Three time delays were determined in the quadruply imaged quasar HE0435–1223, after four years of optical monitoring with Euler, Mercator and Maidanak telescopes, to which photometric measurements by SMARTS 1.3m telescope were added. Euler and SMARTS merged data for the doubly imaged quasar QJ0158–4325 were also analysed, the size of the source accretion disk was measured, but we failed to determine a time delay due to the high amplitude of the microlensing variability in this system. The accuracies on time delay measurements reached in this thesis are of the order of 3-4% and show a clear improvement from the typical 10% uncertainties of past monitoring programs. These results were finally converted into estimates of the Hubble constant following different models of the lensing mass potential. The H0 mean value obtained when considering the individual determinations from twelve gravitationally lensed quasars with known time delays is H0 = 60 ± 7 km s-1 Mpc-1. This result is consistent with the current favored value, and above all promising, as including additional systems to this ensemble will surely provide tighter bounds on H0. In conclusion, the increasing number of time delay measurements and improvements in lens modeling should reduce the errors on the Hubble constant estimate provided by gravitational lensing. Conversely, the determination of more time delays should put further constraints on lens galaxy density profiles when using a prior on H0 from other studies.

EPFL2008

Two Accurate Time-Delay Distances From Strong Lensing: Implications For Cosmology

Frédéric Courbin, Georges Meylan, Malte Tewes

Strong gravitational lenses with measured time delays between the multiple images and models of the lens mass distribution allow a one-step determination of the time-delay distance, and thus a measure of cosmological parameters. We present a blind analysis of the gravitational lens RXJ1131-1231 incorporating (1) the newly measured time delays from COSMOGRAIL, the COSmological MOnitoring of GRAvItational Lenses, (2) archival Hubble Space Telescope imaging of the lens system, (3) a new velocity-dispersion measurement of the lens galaxy of 323 +/- 20 km s(-1) based on Keck spectroscopy, and (4) a characterization of the line-of-sight structures via observations of the lens' environment and ray tracing through the Millennium Simulation. Our blind analysis is designed to prevent experimenter bias. The joint analysis of the data sets allows a time-delay distance measurement to 6% precision that takes into account all known systematic uncertainties. In combination with the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe seven-year (WMAP7) data set in flat wCDM cosmology, our unblinded cosmological constraints for RXJ1131-1231 are H-0 = 80.0(-5.7)(+5.8) km s(-1) Mpc(-1), Omega(de) = 0.79 +/- 0.03, and w = -1.25(-0.21)(+0.17). We find the results to be statistically consistent with those from the analysis of the gravitational lens B1608+ 656, permitting us to combine the inferences from these two lenses. The joint constraints from the two lenses and WMAP7 are H-0 = 75.2(-4.2)(+4.4) km s(-1) Mpc(-1), Omega(de) = 0.76(-0.03)(+0.02), and w = -1.14(-0.20)(+0.17) in flat wCDM, and H-0 = 73.1(-3.6)(+2.4) km s(-1) Mpc(-1), Omega(Lambda) = 0.75(-0.02)(+0.01), and Omega(k) = 0.003(-0.006)(+0.005) in open Lambda CDM. Time-delay lenses constrain especially tightly the Hubble constant H0 (5.7% and 4.0% respectively in wCDM and open Lambda CDM) and curvature of the universe. The overall information content is similar to that of Baryon Acoustic Oscillation experiments. Thus, they complement well other cosmological probes, and provide an independent check of unknown systematics. Our measurement of the Hubble constant is completely independent of those based on the local distance ladder method, providing an important consistency check of the standard cosmological model and of general relativity.