Micropollutant Oxidation Studied by Quantum Chemical Computations: Methodology and Applications to Thermodynamics, Kinetics, and Reaction Mechanisms

The abatement of organic micropollutants during oxidation processes has become an emerging issue for various urban water systems such as drinking water, wastewater, and water reuse. Reaction kinetics and mechanisms play an important role in terms of efficiency of these processes and the formation of transformation products, which are controlled by functional groups in the micropollutants and the applied oxidants. So far, the kinetic and mechanistic information on the underlying reactions was obtained by experimental studies; additionally, predictive quantitative structure activity relationships (QSARs) were applied to determine reaction kinetics for the oxidation of emerging compounds. Since this experimental approach is very laborious and there are tens of thousands potential contaminants, alternative strategies need to be developed to predict the fate of micropollutants during oxidative water treatment. Due to significant developments in quantum chemical (QC) computations in recent years and increased computational capacity, QC based methods have become an alternative or a supplement to the current experimental approach. This Account provides a critical assessment of the current state-of-the-art of QC-based methods for the assessment of oxidation of micropollutants. Starting from a given input structure, QC computations need to locate energetic minima on the potential energy surface (PES). Then, useful thermodynamic and kinetic information can be estimated by different approaches: Experimentally determined reaction mechanisms can be validated by identification of transition structures on the PES, which can be obtained for addition reactions, heavy atom transfer (Cl,+ Br', 0-) and H atom transfer (simultaneous proton and electron transfer) reactions. However, transition structures in the PES cannot be obtained for e--transfer reactions. Second-order rate constants k for the reactions of micropollutants with chemical oxidants can be obtained by ab initio calculations or by QSARs with various QC descriptors. It has been demonstrated that second-order rate constants from ab initio calculations are within factors 3-750 of the measured values, whereas QSAR-based methods can achieve factors 2-4 compared to the experimental data. The orbital eigenvalue of the highest occupied molecular orbital (EHomo) is the most commonly used descriptor for QSAR-based computations of k-values. In combination with results from experimental studies, QC computations can also be applied to investigate reaction mechanisms for verification/understanding of oxidative mechanisms, calculation of branching ratios or regioselectivity, evaluation of the experimental product distribution and assessment of substitution effects. Furthermore, other important physical-chemical constants such as unknown equilibria for species, which are not measurable due to low concentrations, or plc values of reactive transient species can be estimated. With further development of QC-based methods, it will become possible to implement kinetic and mechanistic information from such computations in in silico models to predict oxidative transformation of micropollutants. Such predictions can then be complemented by tailored experimental studies to confirm/falsify the computations.

Computational Quantum Chemical Studies on Radicals

Peter Rudolf Tentscher

Radicals play an important role in many areas of chemistry, such as atmospheric, aquatic, polymer, and biological, to name a few. Radicals are often highly reactive species which are short-lived and therefore harder to study by experimental techniques. In principle, computational quantum chemistry enables the study of arbitrary chemical species, including elusive radicals. However, the approximate quantum chemical methods which are used for production simulations need to be validated for the type of problem in question. First, it is necessary to validate that highly accurate reference methods commonly applied to closed-shell systems are equally applicable to radicals. I show that the “gold standard” for closed-shell systems (coupled cluster with singles, doubles, and perturbative triples excitations (CCSD(T))) can produce molecular geometries and vibrational frequencies suitable for (sub-)kJ/mol thermochemistry for radical species as well. However, additional diagnosis is necessary, especially for vibrational frequency calculations. Coupled cluster methods are then used to compute benchmark binding energies between small radicals and water or hydrogen fluoride as a proxy to the aqueous condensed phase. I find that many common density functional theory (DFT) methods cannot reproduce these binding energies to within chemical accuracy (1 kcal/mol). However, some functionals, for example MPW1K and BHandHLYP, perform better than others. If more accurate ab initio methods are computationally too demanding for the system of interest, these DFT methods should be used for (micro-)solvated radicals. Complexes of radicals with polar solvent are found to be more strongly bound than expected. This can not be explained by dispersive and electrostatic interactions alone. Using natural bond orbitals, I show that additional donor-acceptor interactions may be responsible for the strong intermolecular binding observed. One of the most fundamental processes involving aqueous organic radicals is the one-electron oxidation of closed-shell organics. I study the vertical ionization of neutral organics. That is, the ionization is faster than the reorganization of the solvent (and solute), and the conformation is assumed to be unchanged during the ionization process. I find that the difference between the gas-phase and aqueous-phase vertical ionization energy, ∆VIE = VIEaq − VIEgas, ranges from ≈ 0 to -1.0 eV for small aromatic compounds. The differences in ∆VIE between different compounds seem to be caused by the solvent structures of the ≈ 70 water molecules closest to the solute. In natural surface waters, oxidized organics arise through the reaction of photochemically created radicals with organic molecules already present in the water column. One example for such a reaction is the oxidation of sulfonamide antibiotics. I show that upon oxidation of sulfadiazine and related compounds, an aniline radical cation is formed. The reactivity of this oxidized species is strikingly different from its reduced counterpart: the barrier for a nucleophilic attack on the aniline ring is drastically lowered, and a fast rearrangement reaction can take place. I demonstrate that current quantum chemical protocols are suitable for mechanistic studies of solvated radicals, and I successfully apply them to such problems. To achieve chemical accuracy for quantum computational protocols, further developments are necessary. To validate novel approaches, the benchmark data presented in this thesis may be used.

EPFL2013

Bridging Static and Dynamical Descriptions of Chemical Reactions: An ab Initio Study of CO2 Interacting with Water Molecules

Wanda Andreoni, Fabio Pietrucci

Extracting reliable thermochemical parameters from molecular dynamics simulations of chemical reactions, although based on ab initio methods, is generally hampered by difficulties in reproducing the results and controlling the statistical errors. This is a serious drawback with respect to the quantum chemical description based on potential energy surfaces. This work is an attempt to fill this gap. We apply molecular dynamics, based on density functional theory (DFT) and empowered by path metadynamics (MTD), to simulate the reaction of CO2 with (one, two, and three) water molecules in the gas phase. This study relies on a strategy that ensures a precise control of the accuracy of the reaction coordinates and of the reconstructed free-energy surface on this space, namely, on (i) fully reversible MTD simulations, (ii) a committor probability analysis for the diagnosis of the collective variables, and (iii) a cluster analysis for the characterization of the reconstructed free energy surfaces. This robust procedure permits a meaningful comparison with more traditional calculations of the potential energy surfaces that we also perform within the same DFT computational scheme. This comparison shows in particular that the reactants and products of systems with only three water molecules can no longer be understood in terms of one structure but must be described as statistical configuration ensembles. Calculations carried out with different prescriptions for the exchange-correlation functionals also allow us to establish their quantitative effect on the activation barriers for the formation and the dissociation of carbonic acid. Their decrease induced by the addition of one water molecule (catalytic effect) is found to be largely independent of the specific functional.

Amer Chemical Soc2012

Molecular mechanism of NDMA formation from N,N-dimethylsulfamide during ozonation: Quantum chemical insights into a bromide-catalyzed pathway

Jeremy Samuel Arey, Michèle Bernadette Heeb, Brijesh Kumar Mishra, Daniela Trogolo, Urs von Gunten

During ozonation of drinking water, the fungicide metabolite NN-dimethyIsulfamide (DMS) can be transformed into a highly toxic product, N-nitrosodimethylamine (NDMA). We used quantum chemical computations and stopped-flow experiments to evaluate a chemical mechanism proposed previously to describe this transformation. Stopped-flow experiments indicate a pK(a) = 10.4 for DMS. Experiments show that hypobromous acid (HOBr), generated by ozone oxidation of naturally occurring bromide, brominates the deprotonated DMS- anion with a near-diffusion controlled rate constant (7.1 +/- 0.6 X 10(8) M-1 s(-1)), forming Br-DMS- anion. According to quantum chemical calculations, Br-DMS has a pK(a) similar to 9.0 and thus temains partially deprotonated at neutral pH. The anionic Br-DMS- bromamine can react with ozone with a high rate constant (105 2.5 M-1 s(-1)), forming the reaction intermediate (BrNO)(SO2)N(CH3)(2)(-). This intermediate resembles a loosely bound complex between an electrophilic nitrosyl bromide (BrNO) molecule and an electron-rich dimethylaminosulfinate ((SO2)N(CH3)(2)(-)) fragment, based on inspection of computed natural charges and geometric parameters. This fragile complex undergoes immediate (10(10 +/- 2.5) s(-1)) reaction by two branches: an exothermic channel that produces NDMA, and an entropy-driven channel giving non-NDMA products. Computational results bring new insights into the electronic nature, chemical equilibria, and kinetics of the elementary reactions of this pathway, enabled by computed energies of structures that are not possible to access experimentally.

Amer Chemical Soc2015

Computational Quantum Chemical Studies on Radicals

Peter Rudolf Tentscher

EPFL2013