Factors influencing photocatalytic drinking water detoxification and disinfection by suspended and fixed TiO2

The work presented in this thesis was carried out in the framework of two European projects: SOLWATER, and AQUACAT. The global objective of those projects, including the present work, was to set an autonomous system for drinking water production in developing countries using solar energy. More specifically, the technology of drinking water decontamination by photocatalysis using inexpensive TiO2 catalyst and free of charge sun energy was investigated. In details, the research project dealt with the correlation of the TiO2 physicochemical characteristics with its photocatalytic activity on both organic and bacterial removal, the comparison of the photoactivity of suspended and fixed TiO2, and the development of a large scale prototype for fixed catalyst system. Finally, this work also included the creation of a mathematical model to predict the photo and photocatalytic bacterial inactivation. In photocatalytic experiments, phenolic compounds (phenol, 4-nitrophenol, 4-hydroxybenzoic acid and gallic acid) and benzoic acid were used as model organics, and E. coli as model bacterium. The titania physicochemical characteristics, crystalline structure, specific surface area (BET), particle size, aggregate size, and isoelectric point (IEP) of 13 different suspended TiO2 samples were determined and correlated with photocatalytic activity for chemicals and bacteria abatement. Organics degradation kinetics were found to be significantly affected by the TiO2 surface charge, i.e. the IEP. Indeed, the organic compounds degradation was greatly enhanced by negatively charged TiO2 samples. BET affected differently the primary compounds degradation and the total organic carbon mineralization. The primary degradation kinetics of strongly adsorbed pollutants was enhanced by large BET. Whereas, there was an optimum BET value for a total organic carbon removal, for all organic compounds studied. In addition, the mixed crystalline structure anatase-rutile, in the form of the commercially available Degussa P25, was more active for the purpose of organic degradation than pure anatase TiO2. Bacteria abatement was not influenced by BET specific surface area, particle and aggregate size of suspended TiO2. However, surface charge was crucial for the TiO2 and bacteria interaction. Indeed, negatively charged TiO2 were not efficient in inactivating E. coli, probably due to electrostatic repulsions with the negatively charged E. coli outer membrane. Depending on the nature of the contaminants, different catalyst characteristics have to be considered with regards to TiO2 efficiency on water detoxification and disinfection. Thus, it is not possible to draw a general scheme to determine which photocatalyst is the most suitable for the decontamination of particular water. Comparison of suspended and fixed catalyst revealed that the system with suspended TiO2 is more efficient for bacteria inactivation, yet the post-treatment catalyst filtration presents a serious disadvantage compared to fixed TiO2. Large scale experiments in compound parabolic collector (CPC) prototype reactor with fixed TiO2 revealed that a significant photocatalytic effect appeared only at a low bacterial initial concentration (≤ 103 CFU/ml). High organic compounds removal efficiency with fixed TiO2 was observed at laboratory and large scales, with kinetics similar to the ones obtained with suspended TiO2. A mathematical model was developed to predict bacterial photo-inactivation as a function of the light intensity and of the bacteria physiological state. The modelled curves fitted well with the experimental results for both exponential and stationary phases. Moreover, bacteria were more sensitive to light irradiation in the exponential than in the stationary state. Solar photocatalysis with fixed TiO2 was shown to be an efficient technology for organic pollutant removal and could be used as complement to other treatment process. Indeed, due to the slow bacteria inactivation kinetics observed, the technology needs further development to be used as a unique drinking-water treatment.

Influence of the protein environment on spectroscopy and ultrafast dynamics of retinal in bacteriorhodopsin

Selma Schenkl

The environment is important for the exact course of a chemical reaction. As an example of the strong influence of the environment on the reaction, this work studies the isomerization reaction of the chromophore retinal in the binding pocket of the protein bacteriorhodopsin. Three selected distance scales with reference to the chromophore are addressed: The distant protein surface at a length scale of 3-5 nm, the fuzzy environment of the binding pocket (1-2 nm) and the immediate neighborhood represented by the amino acid tryptophan Trp86 (5 Å). First, static absorption and fluorescence spectroscopies are applied to three dimensionally crystallized bacteriorhodopsin. An especially adapted set-up was developed for each task. The analysis of data is carried out in comparison with the measured spectra of the native protein membrane in solution. While the absorption spectrum shows a broadening on the high-energy side, the fluorescence spectrum deviates in the general shape of that measured in solution. The synoptic analysis of all spectra reveals the existence of three spectroscopically distinct species in the crystal: BR490 (absorption maximum at 490 nm) with a relative contribution of 28%, BR570 (native spectrum of solution, 68%), and BR610 ("blue membrane", 4%). BR490 appears particularly in the additional fluorescence band at 550 nm and is assigned to the dehydrated species of bacteriorhodopsin. The presence of that particular species indicates the suppression of rehydration in a partially dehydrated crystal and shows that the three dimensional arrangement hinders water diffusion. A simple model, close domains are assumed to form, eventually suppressing free water diffusion in a crystal. The lack of water on the protein surface modifies the protonation states of the amino acids in the binding pocket and therefore the optical properties of the retinal. The chromophore actually reacts on the alteration of its distant environment upon incorporation in the protein crystal. The second distance scale - the fuzzy environment - is addressed by a time-integrated fluorescence spectroscopy on native bacteriorhodopsin as function of the excitation wavelength (430 nm to 650 nm). The optimized experimental set-up guaranteed that the fluorescence of only the excited state I460 contributed. The measured spectra show maxima at 740 nm, and exhibit a Stokes shift of 5000 cm-1, independent of the excitation wavelength. The similarity of the fluorescence excitation spectrum with the spectrum of absorbed photons excludes energy-dependent loss channels. However, the spectra show a growing asymmetric broadening on the high-energy side with decreasing excitation wavelength. The additional fluorescence originates from vibrational hot states, also supported by the decomposition by Gaussian functions. A comparison with the fluorescence spectrum of blue membranes shows that the low-energy part also arises from vibrational hot states. Consequently, the first fast intramolecular vibrational energy relaxation does not entirely distribute the access-energy to other modes. The remaining energy is found in a quasi-static occupation of vibrational modes. The subsequent second vibrational relaxation — probably not only involving the retinal but also the protein — takes place on a time scale similar to that of the isomerization. The fast isomerization reaction prevents dissipation of energy relaxation of the excited state of the retinal into the protein environment. On a third distance scale, femtosecond spectroscopy in the UV offers a direct view into the electrostatic interaction of the chromophore with its immediate neighborhood. For the first time, the retinal isomerization was studied within the spectral window of the tryptophan absorption from 265 nm to 310 nm. For this, a set-up adapted to UV wavelengths was realized, basing on non-linear optics. The developed single-shot detection system yields a sensitivity of 10-5 in optical density. In the transient absorption measurements, a time resolution of 90 fs was achieved. At short probe wavelengths (265 nm - 294 nm), the measured transients show first a fast reduction of the absorption which subsequently recovers on three time scales (380 fs, 3 ps, > 16 ps). With increasing probe wavelength an induced transient absorption becomes dominant (282 nm - 294 nm). It has a rise time of 280 fs, and decays with a time constant of 4.3 ps. With further increasing probe wavelength the absorption signal decays faster. In response to the complex signature of the transients, an iterative and model-independent transient-decomposition is introduced. A set of three basis elements were identified: one bleach, and two absorption transients. The two induced absorption transients are assigned to retinal. The dynamics of the excited state (I460) in the first retinal-transient is described by two time constants (280 fs and 1 ps). The fast time constant leads to the photoproduct, while the slower one leads back to the ground state, presumably by internal conversion. The 250 fs delayed onset of the second transient (photo-intermediate J) is connected to a wave packet motion in the excited state. This delayed onset of the transient was observed for the first time. It demands a rise time of the J photo-intermediate of only 280 fs. This contrasts common estimates of 500 fs given in literature. For the first time, the temporal behavior of the permanent dipole moment of retinal is observed experimentally. Its evolution is imprinted in the dominant bleach feature (265 nm - 294 nm), originating from tryptophan Trp86. In the excited state, the permanent dipole moment increases strongly within the first 250 fs, and decays exponentially afterwards, following the formation of the photoproduct. However, the related time constant of 380 fs is slightly greater than that of 280 fs of the photoproduct J. This discrepancy may indicate a remaining long-lived polarization of the binding pocket. In brief, by using the intrinsic tryptophan as a probe, the local evolution of the electric field during the isomerization reaction was investigated. Indeed the isomerization reaction is reflected in the immediate environment. The variety of optical spectroscopy provides methods especially adapted for studying the influences of the environment on a chemical reaction. The results achieved here highlight the importance of these influences.

EPFL2004

Redox flow battery and indirect water electrolysis

Véronique Amstutz

The progressive integration of renewable energy sources such as wind turbines and photovoltaic pannels in the current electrical network, and the rise of the electrical mobility, provoke a change of paradigm in the sector of energy management. The increasing variability of the electricity production and consumption profiles, together with the requirement for a reliable supply of energy, necessitates the implementation of energy storage means of different scales and for a wide range of applications. Redox flow batteries (RFBs) are well adapted for buffering the fluctuations of solar or wind energy production. They present a fast response time, can withstand a large number of charge-discharge cycles and their ouput power is independant of their energy capacity. The main limitation of RFBs resides in their low energy density. The objective of the present work was to test a mean to overcome this low energy density. A new concept was developed, which rests on the addition of a second pathway to discharge the RFB. This pathway allows to generate hydrogen and oxygen, without affecting the functioning of the RFB. This concept was called dual-circuit RFB and was patented. RFBs are based on two liquids electrolytes, each stored in a reservoir, and flowing through an electrochemical cell for their electrochemical conversion. Each electrolyte contains one redox couple and Ce(IV)/Ce(III) and V(III)/V(II) were selected as positive and negative redox couples in the RFB developed here. Charge-discharge curves of a VâCe RFB were measured for characterisation purposes and for the preparation of the charged electrolytes. The latter ones can be discharged electrochemically in the RFB to generate electricity (electrochemical discharge mode), or they can be directed in a secondary circuit where they are discharged for the production of hydrogen or oxygen (chemical discharge mode). The chemical discharge of the negative electrolyte consists of the reaction of V(II) with protons to produce hydrogen and V(III). Mo2C was selected as heterogenous catalyst for the characterisation of the reaction. A conversion close to 100% suggested no loss of current. A kinetic analysis provided some insights into the catalytic mechanism of this reaction. The chemical discharge of the positive electrolyte aimed at the conversion of Ce(IV) to Ce(III) by the oxidation of water to oxygen and also necessitates a catalyst. Iridium dioxide (IrO2) and ruthenium dioxide (RuO2) were evaluated in terms of conversion and kinetics. The composition of the positive electrolyte was shown to be of importance for this reaction. To show the feasibility of this concept, a larger-scale demonstrator system was designed based on a 10 kW (40kWh) commercially available vanadium RFB. A characterisation of this RFB was first performed. The design a suitable Mo2C catalyst and its corresponding catalytic bed is also discussed. As a conclusion, the concept developed and experimentally tested in the present work leads to a RFB system which is characterised by two discharge modes, increasing its energy storage capacity and energy density. The dual-circuit RFB also represents a crossing between electrical grid and hydrogen mobility as the hydrogen produced by surplus electricity could be delivered to fuel cell cars. The application of this system in a local distribution electrical network, close to a wind or solar source seems a promising approach.

EPFL2015

Coupling of electrocatalysts to photoabsorbers for solar fuels production

Carlos Gilberto Morales Guio

The direct transformation of sunlight into fuels and chemicals has attracted considerable attention for the potential impact on the storage of solar energies at large scales and the reduction of CO2 emissions. More than 80% of our current global energy consumption comes from the burning of non-renewable fossil fuels which produces enormous quantities of CO2 and contributes to global warming. We believe today that the key to reduce our dependence on exhaustible natural resources and limit the emission of greenhouse gases is the transition to CO2-free renewable energy sources. However, harvesting of energy from renewable sources (i.e. solar, wind, tidal) is intermittent and the deployment of devices for their transformation into useful forms of energy (i.e. electricity, chemicals, fuels, biomass) in a global scale is conditioned upon the improvement in efficiency of the energy storage mechanisms. A promising approach to store energy is the use of sunlight to drive the production of hydrogen fuel from water. Hydrogen produced from water and sunlight can be transformed back to electricity on demand or be used to generate mechanical energy in cars to power the transportation industry. The oxidation of hydrogen generates useable energy and at the same time exhaust clean, carbon-free water as the only product. Therefore, the production of hydrogen using a renewable energy source in an efficient and inexpensive device has the potential to discourage the continued use of fossil fuels and improve our environment. The viability of any mechanism for the storage of sunlight as fuel will depend on the reduction of energy penalties during the transformation process. Electrocatalysts are advanced materials that bring into one active site electrons and molecules in the appropriate orientation to lower activation energy barriers, accelerate rate of transformations and improve overall efficiencies for chemical reactions. The best catalysts for water splitting are precious metals such as Pt, Ir and Ru, which show superior rates of reaction at low overpotentials. However, these noble metals are too expensive and scarce for large scale applications. This thesis summarizes our recent research in the preparation, characterization, and application of Earth-abundant electrocatalysts for solar water splitting. Although in the last decade a great number of efficient and inexpensive electrocatalysts have been reported, methods for the deposition of these materials on the surface of photoabsorbers are rarely reported. This work shows various simple and scalable techniques for the deposition of hydrogen and oxygen evolving electrocatalysts on the surface of photocathodes and photoanodes, respectively. Surface-protected photocahodes were activated for solar hydrogen production in alkaline conditions with MoS2+x, Ni-Mo and Mo2C. A novel method for the deposition of an optically transparent amorphous iron nickel oxide oxygen evolution electrocatalyst is also reported. The catalyst was deposited on both thin film and high-aspect ratio nanostructured hematite photoanodes. The low catalyst loading combined with its high activity at low overpotential results in significant improvement on the onset potential for photoelectrochemical water oxidation. This transparent catalyst further enables the preparation of a stable hematite/perovskite solar cell tandem device, which performs unassisted water splitting.

EPFL2016