Back Electron-Hole Recombination in Hematite Photoanodes for Water Splitting

The kinetic competition between electron-hole recombination and water oxidation is a key consideration for the development of efficient photoanodes for solar driven water splitting. In this study, we employed three complementary techniques, transient absorption spectroscopy (TAS), transient photocurrent spectroscopy (TPC), and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS), to address this issue for one of the most widely studied photoanode systems: nanostructured hematite thin films. For the first time, we show a quantitative agreement between all three techniques. In particular, all three methods show the. presence of a recombination process on the 10 ms to 1 s time scale, with the time scale and yield of this loss process being dependent upon applied bias. From comparison of data between these techniques, we are able to assign this recombination phase to recombination of bulk hematite electrons with long-lived holes accumulated at the semiconductor/electrolyte interface. The data from all three techniques are shown to be consistent with a simple kinetic model based on competition between this, bias dependent, recombination pathway and water oxidation by these long-lived holes. Contrary to most existing models, this simple model does not require the consideration of surface states located energetically inside the band gap. These data suggest two distinct roles for the space charge layer developed at the semiconductor/electrolyte interface under anodic bias. Under modest anodic bias (just anodic of flatband), this space charge layer enables the spatial separation of initially generated electrons and holes following photon absorption, generating relatively long-lived holes (milliseconds) at the semiconductor surface. However, under such modest bias conditions, the energetic barrier generated by the space charge layer field is insufficient to prevent the subsequent recombination of these holes with electrons in the semiconductor bulk on a time scale faster than water oxidation. Preventing this back electron-hole recombination requires the application of stronger anodic bias, and is a key reason why the onset potential for photocurrent generation in hematite photoanodes is typically similar to 500 mV anodic of flat band and therefore needs to be accounted for in electrode design for PEC water splitting.

On the Morphology and Interfaces of Nanostructured Hematite Photoanodes for Solar-Driven Water Splitting

Florian Le Formal

A sustainable route to store the energy provided by the Sun, is to directly convert sunlight into molecular hydrogen using a semiconductor performing water photolysis. Hematite (α-Fe2O3) is promising for this application due to its ample abundance, chemical stability and significant light absorption (with a band gap of 2.0 - 2.2 eV). Despite these advantageous properties, several drawbacks restrain the utilization of iron oxide for photoelectrochemical water splitting. The first limitation, namely the conduction band edge lower than the water reduction potential, can be straightforwardly overcome by adding a second solar system in tandem, which can absorb a complementary part of the solar spectrum and bring the electron at an energetic level higher than the hydrogen evolution potential. The second drawback arises from the disaccord between the short charge carrier diffusion length and the large light penetration depth. It is therefore necessary to control the hematite morphology on a length scale similar to the hole transport length. To further enhance the photoelectrochemical performance, a new concept for water splitting is introduced in this thesis. The host-guest approach consists in decoupling the different tasks of the photoanode (on one side light harvesting and water oxidation center, on the other side electron conduction to the substrate) by depositing a thin layer of hematite onto a mesoporous host (WO3 in this study). This concept has been demonstrated to increase the photocurrent by ca. 20% due to enhanced quantum efficiencies at long wavelengths. This demonstration has been nonetheless limited by the iron oxide thin films overall efficiency. Thin films photoactivity is then investigated by two means: first by controlling their nucleation on a modified substrate and secondly by incorporating plasmonic nanoparticles aimed to localize absorption in the thin film. The formation of a SiOx buffer layer on the substrate prior to deposition of hematite by Fe(acac)3 spray is shown to modify the film formation mode and its physical properties. These films exhibit photoactivity from an optical thickness of 12.5 nm (as compared to 25 nm without underlayer). The study of hematite photoanodes with gold nanoparticles, embedded or deposited on its surface, establish that charge transfer from metal nanoparticles is occurring only at overlapping wavelengths between the plasmonic resonance and the semiconductor absorption. Nevertheless, photoelectrochemical performances are reduced because of high recombination rate at the metal/semiconductor interface. Finally the third limitation, i.e. the large overpotential required to observe the onset of water splitting photocurrent, is tackled in the last part. The onset potential of photocurrent is decreased by a very thin coating of Al2O3 (0.1 - 2 nm), deposited by ALD, on the nanostructured photoanode. The subsequent application of the Co2+ catalyst further reduces the overpotential and results in a record photocurrent at 0.9 VRHE of over 0.4 mA cm-2. This investigation clearly distinguishes two causes for this energy loss: surface traps and slow oxidation kinetics. The charge accumulation and the Fermi level pinning, observed at low bias potential and assigned to these surface states were further rationalized in an investigation on photocurrent and photovoltage transients.

EPFL2011

Hematite photoelectrodes for water splitting: evaluation of the role of film thickness by impedance spectroscopy

Florian Le Formal, Kevin Sivula

The electrochemical behavior of alpha-Fe2O3 photoelectrodes prepared by spray pyrolysis with different thicknesses was examined under dark and illumination conditions. The main charge transport phenomena occurring in the PEC cell photoelectrodes were characterized by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) operating under dark conditions. The impedance spectra were fitted to an equivalent electrical circuit model for obtaining relevant information concerning reaction kinetics and charge transfer phenomena occurring at the semiconductor/electrolyte interface. A three-electrode configuration was used to carry out the electrochemical measurements allowing a detailed study concerning the double charged layer at the semiconductor/electrolyte interface that arises under dark conditions. The model parameters determined by EIS were then related to the film thickness to assess the role of electronic conduction in the performance of the cell. Moreover, by correlating the sample thickness differences with their electrochemical impedance spectroscopy response, it was possible to discriminate the two main phenomena occurring on semiconductor/electrolyte interfaces of photoelectrochemical systems under dark conditions: the space charge layer and the electrical double layer.

Royal Soc Chemistry2014

Influence of Feature Size, Film Thickness, and Silicon Doping on the Performance of Nanostructured Hematite Photoanodes for Solar Water Splitting

Ilkay Cesar, Michael Graetzel, Kevin Sivula

Photoanodes consisting of nanostructured hematite prepared by atmospheric pressure chemical vapor deposition (APCVD) have previously set a benchmark for solar water splitting. Here, we fully investigate this promising system by varying critical synthetic parameters and probing the photoanode performance to determine the major factors that influence operation. By varying the film thickness, we show film growth to be linear with an incubation time. We find no concern with electron transport for films up to 600 nm, but a higher recombination rate of photogenerated carriers in the hematite near the interface with the fluorine-doped tin oxide, as compared to the bulk section of the film. ne mechanism for the formation of the thin film's nanoporous dendritic structure is discussed on the basis of the results from varying the substrate growth temperate. The observed feature sizes of the film are found to depend strongly on this temperature and the presence of silicon dopant precursor (TEOS). Raman and Mossbauer experiments reveal how temperature and doping affect the crystallinity and ultimately the photoperformance. We also use impedance spectroscopy to find evidence for an unusually high donor density, which allows the formation of a space-charge field inside the nanosized features of the polycrystalline hematite photoanode.

2009

On the Morphology and Interfaces of Nanostructured Hematite Photoanodes for Solar-Driven Water Splitting

Florian Le Formal

EPFL2011