Attacks on some post-quantum cryptographic protocols: The case of the Legendre PRF and SIKE

Post-quantum cryptography is a branch of cryptography which deals with cryptographic algorithms whose hardness assumptions are not based on problems known to be solvable by a quantum computer, such as the RSA problem, factoring or discrete logarithms.This thesis treats two such algorithms and provides theoretical and practical attacks against them.The first protocol is the generalised Legendre pseudorandom function - a random bit generator computed as the Legendre symbol of the evaluation of a secret polynomial at an element of a finite field. We introduce a new point of view on the protocol by analysing the action of the group of Möbius transformations on the set of secret keys (secret polynomials).We provide a key extraction attack by creating a table which is cubic in the number of the function queries, an improvement over the previous algorithms which only provided a quadratic yield. Furthermore we provide an ever stronger attack for a new set of particularly weak keys.The second protocol that we cover is SIKE - supersingular isogeny key encapsulation.In 2017 the American National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) opened a call for standardisation of post-quantum cryptographic algorithms. One of the candidates, currently listed as an alternative key encapsulation candidate in the third round of the standardisation process, is SIKE.We provide three practical side-channel attacks on the 32-bit ARM Cortex-M4 implementation of SIKE.The first attack targets the elliptic curve scalar multiplication, implemented as a three-point ladder in SIKE. The lack of coordinate randomisation is observed, and used to attack the ladder by means of a differential power analysis algorithm.This allows us to extract the full secret key of the target party with only one power trace.The second attack assumes coordinate randomisation is implemented and provides a zero-value attack - the target party is forced to compute the field element zero, which cannot be protected by randomisation. In particular we target both the three-point ladder and isogeny computation in two separate attacks by providing maliciously generated public keys made of elliptic curve points of irregular order.We show that an order-checking countermeasure is effective, but comes at a price of 10% computational overhead. Furthermore we show how to modify the implementation so that it can be protected from all zero-value attacks, i.e., a zero-value is never computed during the execution of the algorithm.Finally, the last attack targets a point swapping procedure which is a subroutine of the three-point ladder. The attack successfully extracts the full secret key with only one power trace even if the implementation is protected with coordinate randomisation or order-checking. We provide an effective countermeasure --- an improved point swapping algorithm which protects the implementation from our attack.

Bringing Theory Closer to Practice in Post-quantum and Leakage-resilient Cryptography

Alexandre Raphaël Duc

Modern cryptography pushed forward the need of having provable security. Whereas ancient cryptography was only relying on heuristic assumptions and the secrecy of the designs, nowadays researchers try to make the security of schemes to rely on mathematical problems which are believed hard to solve. When doing these proofs, the capabilities of potential adversaries are modeled formally. For instance, the black-box model assumes that an adversary does not learn anything from the inner-state of a construction. While this assumption makes sense in some practical scenarios, it was shown that one can sometimes learn some information by other means, e.g., by timing how long the computation take. In this thesis, we focus on two different areas of cryptography. In both parts, we take first a theoretical point of view to obtain a result. We try then to adapt our results so that they are easily usable for implementers and for researchers working in practical cryptography. In the first part of this thesis, we take a look at post-quantum cryptography, i.e., at cryptographic primitives that are believed secure even in the case (reasonably big) quantum computers are built. We introduce HELEN, a new public-key cryptosystem based on the hardness of the learning from parity with noise problem (LPN). To make our results more concrete, we suggest some practical instances which make the system easily implementable. As stated above, the design of cryptographic primitives usually relies on some well-studied hard problems. However, to suggest concrete parameters for these primitives, one needs to know the precise complexity of algorithms solving the underlying hard problem. In this thesis, we focus on two recent hard-problems that became very popular in post-quantum cryptography: the learning with error (LWE) and the learning with rounding problem (LWR). We introduce a new algorithm that solves both problems and provide a careful complexity analysis so that these problems can be used to construct practical cryptographic primitives. In the second part, we look at leakage-resilient cryptography which studies adversaries able to get some side-channel information from a cryptographic primitive. In the past, two main disjoint models were considered. The first one, the threshold probing model, assumes that the adversary can put a limited number of probes in a circuit. He then learns all the values going through these probes. This model was used mostly by theoreticians as it allows very elegant and convenient proofs. The second model, the noisy-leakage model, assumes that every component of the circuit leaks but that the observed signal is noisy. Typically, some Gaussian noise is added to it. According to experiments, this model depicts closely the real behaviour of circuits. Hence, this model is cherished by the practical cryptographic community. In this thesis, we show that making a proof in the first model implies a proof in the second model which unifies the two models and reconciles both communities. We then look at this result with a more practical point-of-view. We show how it can help in the process of evaluating the security of a chip based solely on the more standard mutual information metric.

EPFL2015

Quantum Cryptography : On the Security of the BB84 Key-Exchange Protocol

Thomas Baignères

In 1984, C.H. Bennet and G. Brassard proposed a new protocol aimed to solve the problem of symmetric cryptographic key exchange. This protocol was called BB84 after the name of its authors. While a traditional method would rely on public key cryptography (like RSA), the BB84 protocol takes benefit of the laws of quantum mechanics, like for example the fact that any quantum measurement can perturb the system. Traditional public key algorithms security often rely on a typical hard mathematical problem. It is well known for example that the ability to factorize easily any number would make the usage of RSA completely insecure. Quantum Key Exchange (QKE) protocols security cannot be proved in a similar way. In this work, we will try to give an overview of security proofs of quantum key exchange protocols, focusing on the BB84 protocol.

2003

On the Cryptanalysis of Public-Key Cryptography

Joppe Willem Bos

Nowadays, the most popular public-key cryptosystems are based on either the integer factorization or the discrete logarithm problem. The feasibility of solving these mathematical problems in practice is studied and techniques are presented to speed-up the underlying arithmetic on parallel architectures. The fastest known approach to solve the discrete logarithm problem in groups of elliptic curves over finite fields is the Pollard rho method. The negation map can be used to speed up this calculation by a factor √2. It is well known that the random walks used by Pollard rho when combined with the negation map get trapped in fruitless cycles. We show that previously published approaches to deal with this problem are plagued by recurring cycles, and we propose effective alternative countermeasures. Furthermore, fast modular arithmetic is introduced which can take advantage of prime moduli of a special form using efficient "sloppy reduction." The effectiveness of these techniques is demonstrated by solving a 112-bit elliptic curve discrete logarithm problem using a cluster of PlayStation 3 game consoles: breaking a public-key standard and setting a new world record. The elliptic curve method (ECM) for integer factorization is the asymptotically fastest method to find relatively small factors of large integers. From a cryptanalytic point of view the performance of ECM gives information about secure parameter choices of some cryptographic protocols. We optimize ECM by proposing carry-free arithmetic modulo Mersenne numbers (numbers of the form 2M – 1) especially suitable for parallel architectures. Our implementation of these techniques on a cluster of PlayStation 3 game consoles set a new record by finding a 241-bit prime factor of 21181 – 1. A normal form for elliptic curves introduced by Edwards results in the fastest elliptic curve arithmetic in practice. Techniques to reduce the temporary storage and enhance the performance even further in the setting of ECM are presented. Our results enable one to run ECM efficiently on resource-constrained platforms such as graphics processing units.