Modelling of high temperature superconductors for AC power applications

This Ph.D. thesis is focused on the development of novel models for calculation of AC losses, current and magnetic field profiles in high-temperature superconductors (HTS). The thesis is concentrated on the modelling of Bi-2223 conductors at 77 K, which for the moment have the most advanced manufacturing technology and will be primarily used in the first large-scale power applications of high-temperature superconductors. The analysis of AC losses in Bi-2223 conductors is the leading thread in the structure of the thesis. An introduction to high-temperature superconductivity is made with special emphasis on the mechanisms of AC losses in HTS. Presented are some of the most promising power applications of HTS materials together with a discussion on the required improvements in their performance. A model for dissociating the hysteresis, eddy-current and resistive flux-creep loss contributions, based on relatively broad-range frequency measurements on Bi-2223 tapes has been used for analysis of the frequency behaviour of the transport-current loss in self-field. The hysteresis, eddy-current and flux-creep loss components have been separated due to their different frequency dependence. The study of eddy current loss in the silver sheath and matrix has been complimented by numerical simulations using a simple electromagnetic model of HTS tapes. Described is an original method for estimating the performance of Bi-2223 tapes in typical power grid perturbations by experiments and analysis of over-critical current excursions of various waveform, frequency and current amplitude up to 20×Ic. For precise calculation of the AC losses and studying the electromagnetic properties of HTS with smooth current-voltage characteristics and complex geometry, the finite element method (FEM) has been used. The implementation of the power-law model of the E-J characteristic of HTS into the FEM software package Flux2D is presented. The Flux2D implementation has been validated by means of comparison with results from theoretical predictions, electrical measurements, and other numerical methods. The significance of the power index n and the lateral distribution of the critical current density Jc in multifilamentary HTS tapes has been evaluated by FEM simulations. New anisotropic models of Jc(B) and n(B) for textured Bi-2223 materials have been developed. The models are based on experimental data; they are fairly simple and take into account the orientation of the local magnetic field. These models have been used in FEM simulations on monofilamentary and multifilamentary Bi-2223 conductors with different geometry and filament arrangement. In conductors with given Jc(B) dependence, the notion of effective AC critical current has been defined. The AC losses in Bi-2223 multifilamentary flat tapes and wires of round and square geometry in various operating conditions have been calculated and compared. The AC loss analysis has been supported and complimented by current density and magnetic flux distributions in the different conductors. The influence of the shape factor of the geometry and the filament orientation with respect to the local magnetic field has been thoroughly investigated. The optimal geometry and filament arrangement have been determined for each application.

Effect of the geometry of HTS on AC loss by using finite element method simulation with B-dependent E-J power law

Mono and multifilamentary HTS tapes exhibit non-negligible AC loss in self-field and considerably higher losses in the presence of external magnetic field. The effect of the conductor’s geometry on the AC loss has been investigated in this paper. The nonlinear electromagnetic properties of the superconducting material are expressed with a B-dependent E-J power law and are implemented in Finite Element Method commercial software. The critical current density and the power index n dependence on B are obtained from DC measurements of a real Bi-2223 tape. AC loss comparison between monofilamentary conductors of rectangular, elliptical, square and round geometry has been performed in self-field and applied external perpendicular magnetic field. The areas of the cross-section and the superconducting-core-to-Ag ratio have been kept constant in the simulations. To complement the AC loss analysis, the distribution of the current density and the magnetic field of the different geometries are presented.

2001

Numerical modelling of high temperature superconducting tapes and cables

Francesco Grilli

This Ph.D. thesis is focused on the numerical modelling of high-Tc superconductors (HTS) at the operating temperature of 77 K (liquid nitrogen). The purpose of numerical modelling is to precisely calculate the current and field distributions inside HTS devices (tapes, cables) and the corresponding AC losses, which are one of the most important limiting factors for a large-scale application of such materials. From the electrical point of view, superconductors are characterized by a strongly non-linear voltage-current relation, which defines the transition from superconducting to normal state. In the case of HTS, the steepness of this transition is smoother than for low-Tc superconductors (LTS), so that the commonly used critical state model (CSM) gives a too simplified representation of their electromagnetic behaviour and can be used for a qualitative description only. In this thesis the finite element method (FEM) has been used for precisely computing the current and field distributions as well as for evaluating the AC losses in HTS devices. The superconducting transition is modelled with a power-law relation, E(J) = Ec(J/Jc)n, which is derived from the fit of transport measurements. Firstly, the results obtained with the software package FLUX3D on multi-filamentary tapes have been validated by means of a comparison with the ones obtained by another software package (FLUX2D). The results from FLUX2D, having already been successfully compared with experimental measurements within the framework of two previous Ph.D. theses at LANOS, have been used as reference. Secondly, two power-law models, which take into account the spatial variation of the critical current density inside HTS tapes and its strongly anisotropic dependence on the magnetic field, have been implemented in FLUX3D. In most cases, this latter dependence is extremely important, since the transport capacity of the superconductor is considerably reduced (and its power loss sensibly increased) by the presence of a magnetic field. Afterwards, FEM modelling of HTS tapes has been extended to cables. HTS cables are in general composed by different layers of several tapes and have a quite complex three-dimensional structure: in fact, the layers are wound around a central cylindrical support with different pitch lengths and relative winding orientations, in order to obtain a uniform repartition of the transport current among the layers, which minimizes the total AC losses. For overcoming the difficulties of a direct 3D FEM simulation, a simple electrical model, which allows to find the optimal pitch lengths and whose results are the input data for a 2D FEM evaluation of the AC losses, has been developed. FEM computations have also been used to investigate the influence of the non-uniformity of the tape properties (contact resistance, critical current, power index) on the global loss performance of a single-layer HTS cable. As an alternative to FEM computations, an equivalent circuit model of HTS cables has been utilized. It describes the cable from the macroscopic point of view and allows to compute the current repartition among the layers and the corresponding AC losses, without the necessity of having detailed information about individual tapes. In the framework of the European project BIG-POWA, I have collaborated to the assembling process of a HTS power-link at the Pirelli Labs, in the Milan region, Italy. Finally, 3D simulations have been performed to extensively study the coupling effect between two superconducting filaments via the resistive matrix, which is a typical case where analytical solutions exist for very peculiar geometries and physical conditions only. FEM simulations have been utilized to study the dependence of the filament coupling on the physical and geometrical parameters of the conductors.

EPFL2004

Finite element method simulation of ac loss in HTS tapes with B-dependent E-J power law

Bertrand Dutoit

The nonlinear behavior of High Temperature Superconductors (HTS) is often modeled by an E-J power law in order to describe their electromagnetic properties. This paper presents AC loss calculations in HTS tapes, performed by means of FEM commercial software using the A-V method. The implemented nonlinear model of the HTS tapes takes into account the B-dependence of the critical current density Jc and the power index n. The expressions for Jc(B) and n(B) are obtained from electrical measurements of a Bi-2223 tape under applied DC magnetic field. Numerical simulations of HTS tapes under different experimental conditions have been performed, i.e. the application of a transport current and/or AC external perpendicular magnetic field at 59 Hz. A comparative analysis of AC loss is then presented where Jc and n are maintained either constant or B-dependent. The combined Jc(B) and n(B) formulation leads to a better understanding of HTS electromagnetic behavior, especially when a perpendicular magnetic field is applied.

2001

Numerical modelling of high temperature superconducting tapes and cables

Francesco Grilli

EPFL2004