Going beyond limits in Brillouin distributed fibre sensors: Challenges and possible approaches

Brillouin distributed optical fibre sensing has been a subject of intense research and industrial development for more than twenty years, demonstrating its capabilities to be an effective and powerful measurement tool for a wide range of applications. Making use of sophisticated implementations, remarkable progresses on the sensing performance have been reported in the last decade, allowing significant improvements in spatial resolution and sensing range. However, the demand for distributed sensors with more performing features is steadily growing, imposing new and more challenging requirements to the sensor design. This paper presents a brief overview of the fundamentals of Brillouin distributed fibre sensing and reviews the main current limitations and challenges faced when the sensing capabilities are pushed beyond the state-of-the-art. Different possible approaches and methods to enhance and compare the sensing performance are also discussed.

La diffusion Brillouin dans les fibres optiques

Among all non-linear optical effects observed in single-mode optical fibres, stimulated Brillouin scattering (SBS) is of particular importance since it has numerous practical implications. SBS occurs when laser waves are scattered through the interaction of light with hypersonic acoustic waves in the medium. It manifests through the generation of a backscattered Stokes wave that carries most of the input optical power once a definite intensity level is reached within the fibre core. It limits the maximum optical power that can be transmitted through an optical fibre and therefore can cause a severe penality for fibre optics telecommunications. The backscattered Stokes wave is down shifted in frequency with respect to the incident lightwave frequency. This frequency shift – often called the Brillouin frequency shift – depends on the fibre parameters and on the wavelength of the incident light. It is directly proportional to the acoustic velocity and ranges from 12 to 13 GHz for silica fibres at a 1.3 µm wavelength. The Brillouin frequency shift is also very sensitive to environmental quantities changing the acoustic velocity such as temperature and strain. This feature makes SBS very interesting for temperature and strain monitoring in optical fibres and has been used in the design of fibre optics sensors. In the present work, a novel method to measure SBS characteristics in single-mode optical fibres has been developed. It is based on the so-called pump and probe technique using two counterpropagating optical waves within the test fibre. It basically presents the originality to require only one laser source and relies on an electro-optic modulator to generate the probe signal by microwave modulation of the pump light. The inherent high stability of the experimental set-up has made possible the characterisation of different fibres in terms of SBS parameters with a higher accuracy than the traditional two lasers set-up. The influence of dopant concentration in silica fibres on the SBS properties has been fully characterised. Furthermore it has been determined that the presence of core dopants decreases the acoustic velocity resulting in a smaller Brillouin frequency shift. The temperature and strain effects on the SBS characteristics have been extensively investigated. The problem of the evolution of the polarisation of the interacting lightwaves has been studied and a model clarified the so far unexplained behaviour in low birefringence fibres. A new measurement procedure has been defined to achieve polarisation-independent Brillouin gain determination. The second facet of the present thesis deals with the concept of distributed fibre optics sensors based on SBS. The determination of the Brillouin frequency shift gives access to the temperature or strain experienced by the fibre, while a modified OTDR technique provides the information on the position. Here again the use of a single laser source together with an electro-optic modulator brings several advantages. Besides the convenient flexibility in the generation of the probe signal, it makes possible to pulse the optical signals to localise the interaction within the test fibre. The overall temperature or strain distribution of the test fibre can be carried out by measuring the Brillouin frequency shift at any locations throughout the test fibre. A sensor has been experimentally achieved and its performances can be summarised as follow: spatial resolution less than 10 meters over more than 10 kilometres, with a resolution on the Brillouin frequency determination of 1 MHz, that corresponds to a ±1°C temperature resolution or to a 2x10-5 strain resolution. The dynamic range can be increased up to 30 kilometres to the detriment of the spatial resolution. The ultimate performances of the SBS distributed fibre optics sensors have been investigated in terms of spatial resolution and dynamic range. It turns out that these sensors are eventually dedicated to distributed measurements over several tens of kilometres with a spatial resolution limited to the meter range. Finally two practical applications of such sensors are described: the measurement of the strain distribution in installed fibre optics cables for telecommunications and the temperature monitoring of electrical energy distribution cables. On site measurements using a Brillouin sensor have been performed for the first time thanks to the high stability and reliability of the sensor.

EPFL1997

Distributed sensing using polarization sensitive optical low-coherence reflectometry and fiber gratings

Dragan Coric

Optical low coherence reflectometry (OLCR) is non-destructive interferometric technique that allows measuring amplitude and phase of the light reflected from the device under test. OLCR is a powerful tool for the characterization of the various optical devices such as fiber gratings and optical waveguides. This thesis work had explored possibilities to combine the OLCR technique with fiber gratings to perform distributed strain and temperature measurements, and to develop novel sensing techniques as an alternative to classical spectral methods. Special attention is devoted to polarization sensitive measurements and techniques, and OLCR techniques that use only amplitude information, as an alternative to more complicated phase sensitive measurements. Using a polarization sensitive system two methods for the measurement of local birefringence of fiber Bragg gratings (FBG) using OLCR were developed. The first technique uses oscillations in the OLCR amplitude signal to directly obtain the beat length and the birefringence. The second method is based on the measurement of the OLCR phase and inverse scattering algorithm. Both methods were compared with birefringence obtained from spectral measurements, and very good agreement was obtained. The indirect method, based on local Bragg grating determination requires two independent measurements and mathematical reconstruction, but provides a very high spatial resolution of ≈ 25 µm. The grating length limits the minimum measurable birefringence in the direct method, but a good sensitivity of 4×10-6 was obtained, which corresponds to a Bragg wavelength shift of 4 pm. The spatial resolution is in the millimeter range in this case. The novel methods were successfully applied for the distributed measurement of birefringence of FBG under diametric load. New types of tunable devices and sensors – fiber Bragg gratings written in high attenuation fibers (HAF) were developed. Active tuning by heating was achieved by optical pumping of a pure single mode fiber without any mechanical or electrical parts, or deposited light absorption coatings. Tuning can be controlled by the applied pump power, the position of the grating, the HAF attenuation level, and the pumping configuration. The proposed design assures a high repeatability and long lifetime. Using OLCR these devices were successfully applied to measure the liquid level with a spatial resolution of 100 micrometers. Liquid level measurements that use both phase and amplitude, or only amplitude were demonstrated. The same principles could be easily applied to design other fiber grating devices (long-period, tilted etc), and sensors based on hot-wire anemometry, like flow or vacuum sensors.

EPFL2007

Brillouin Distributed Fibre Sensing: State of the Art and Perspectives

Luc Thévenaz

Developed societies require more and more information for their safety and for their economic development. Recent disasters due to landslides, fires in tunnels and collapses of bridges are a source of serious concern on the part of the public which seeks for more safety and for an efficient prevention of these frequent recurrences of dangers. Sensing in adverse environment and extreme conditions requires dedicated techniques. Quite recent technologies may offer novel valuable solutions and give rise to a strenuous research effort. Optical technologies are an essential actor owing to their tremendous capability to transmit and process a high density of information. Optical fibre is a key component for these technologies and its potential for optical processing and for collecting information as sensing probe is still widely unexplored. The development and the popularity of telecommunications have entirely screened the fact that optical fibres may be efficiently used for sensing purposes. In this paper we present applications of a novel technique using optical fibres to monitor large structures for safety purpose. The fibre is used as sensing element and can provide distributed measurements of quantities like temperature or strain. In other words a value of temperature and/or strain can be obtained for any point along the fibre. This is made possible by using a nonlinear optical effect in the fibre called Stimulated Brillouin Scattering (SBS). Optical fibre sensors based on stimulated Brillouin scattering have now clearly demonstrated their excellent capability for long-range distributed strain and temperature measurements. The Brillouin interaction causes the coupling between optical and acoustic waves when a resonance condition is fulfilled. It turns out that this resonance condition is strain and temperature-dependent, so that determining the resonance frequency directly provides a measure of temperature or strain. The resonance frequency is an intrinsic property of the material that may be observed in any silica fibre. This is very attractive since the bare fibre itself acts as sensing element without any special processing or preparation on the fibre. Standard optical cables may thus be used, resulting in a low-cost sensing element that may be left in the structure. Since the optical effect only depends on the fibre material, it is absolutely stable in time and independent of the instrument. Different measurements performed over a long-term period are thus fully comparable. The latest developments in this class of sensors will be shown, such as the possibility to measure with a spatial resolution of 10 cm and below, while preserving the full accuracy on the determination of temperature and strain. Illustrative examples of site measurements will be presented and future prospects will be discussed.

Materials Research Society of Singapore2009