Defect chemistry of methylammonium lead iodide

The present work deals with the defect chemistry and charge transport properties in halide perovskites, and in particular in the archetypal methylammonium lead iodide. These materials are extensively researched due to their very promising application as light-harvesters in solar cells and in other optoelectronic devices. Notwithstanding the numerous studies dealing with these materials (especially with their optical and electronic properties, and with device application), a significant portion of the underlying physics and chemistry is still poorly understood. Indeed, the physico-chemical features behind their exceptional photo-electrochemical properties are still largely unknown. Moreover, these materials suffer from severe degradation processes presently impeding their practical application. In addition, the charge transport in these materials is not purely electronic, but rather shows a significant ionic portion due to mobile ionic defects. The nature of such ion conduction, alongside its effect on the photo-electrochemical properties and on the materials stability, has never been systematically investigated. The study of these aspects is the aim of this thesis, where: At first, we study the charge transport properties of methylammonium lead iodide, with particular attention to the ionic contribution, and we perform a defect chemical study of the compound. We show how the ionic conductivity, in equilibrium conditions, can be unambiguously assigned to mobile iodine vacancies, with an electronic contribution due to electron holes or conduction electron depending on the iodine activity. Secondly, we investigate the light effect on the charge transport previously characterized. Alongside an expected increase of the electronic contribution, we observe a striking enhancement of ionic conductivity in methylammonium lead iodide upon illumination. This remarkable observation is of fundamental relevance for both photovoltaics and solid state ionics fields. Here we also discuss a mechanism for such photo-enhanced ion conduction that relies on electron-ion interaction. Subsequently, we analyze methylammonium lead iodide and other hybrid halide perovskites under oxygen exposure, both in the dark and under illumination. We show that light strongly affects the kinetics of oxygen interaction, so much so that under illumination methylammonium lead iodide completely degrades, while it is metastable in the dark. The oxygen, when incorporated in a sufficient amount in the lattice, also acts as acceptor dopant, greatly varying the ionic and electronic conductivities. We then investigate stability of several halide perovskites with respect to temperature, oxygen, and illumination through thermodynamic considerations. Here we show how many of these processes are expected to be extremely severe for some of the compounds, underlining an important -and intrinsic- bottleneck for the application of these materials. At last, we investigate the short-range ion dynamics in methylammonium lead iodide, since these are linked to stability and electronic transport properties. Here, we show that methylammonium dynamics conforms well to a fast bi-axial rotation becoming isotropic in the cubic phase. In the inorganic lattice, a strong nuclear coupling between Pb and I is present, alongside highly active iodine dynamics.

La0.5Sr0.5Fe1-yMyO3-[delta] (M = Ti, Ta) perovskite oxides for oxygen separation membranes

Defne Bayraktar

Mixed ionic electronic conducting perovskite materials have been receiving considerable attention for the application of oxygen separation membranes. These membranes have potential to be integrated in industrial processes that require pure oxygen and to provide advantages considering economical and environmental aspects. The used perovskite materials can accommodate a high concentration of disordered oxygen vacancies and provide high oxygen permeation flux in the presence of an oxygen partial pressure gradient. However, the materials with high oxygen flux are observed to have low chemical and mechanical stability, originating from oxygen vacancy formation and reduction of the B-site transition metal ion. Based on the fact that the stability of the materials at reducing pO2 is dependent on the redox stability of the B-site cation, a partial substitution of the B-site transition metal with a more stable cation is considered in this thesis to improve the stability of the base perovskite oxide. The approach used for the identification of the suitable material based on the host composition La0.5Sr0.5FeO3-δ (LSF) was to first explore the B-site substituting elements in terms of their effect on the thermal expansion and the isothermal expansion measured during the atmosphere change from air to argon. The elements Al, Cr, Zr, Ga, Ti, Sn, Ta, In, V, and Mg were used for 10 or 20% substitution of Fe. The isothermal expansion of the host material was decreased by substitution, which was attributed to decreased amount of oxygen vacancy formation as it was evidenced later by TGA of chosen compositions. As a result, the compositions substituted with higher valence ions (particularly, 20% Ti4+, LSFTi2, and 10% Ta5+, LSFTa1) were identified as the least expanding materials in isothermal conditions. The effect of substitution was further characterized extensively including structural, mechanical, and oxygen transport properties. The oxygen vacancy (VO••) concentration changes induced by substitution of Fe were reflected in unit cell sizes of heat-treated samples under argon atmosphere. The increase in the unit cell size was attributed to the isothermal expansion due to B-site reduction and lowered to half in case of substituted LSFTi2 and LSFTa1 compared to the host material LSF. Similar trends were observed for interrelated properties such as the coefficient of thermal expansion, isothermal expansion, and the actual amount of oxygen vacancies formed under argon at 900°C, all of which were higher for LSF. The mechanical properties of LSF, LSFTi2, and LSFTa1 were characterized at room temperature. The Young's modulus and the bending strength of the materials were in the same range (141-147 GPa and ∼120 MPa, respectively) while the fracture toughness of the LSF sample was improved by Ti and especially Ta substitution. The fractography of the samples provided evidence that the several LSF samples showed extended cracks possibly related to residual stresses forming during cooling, due to non-equilibrated oxygen stoichiometry across the sample. The potential step measurements showed that the chemical diffusion and the surface exchange coefficients measured during oxidation of the samples were higher than the ones measured during reduction of the samples. The tendency was reversed at lowered pO2 along with the decrease of both coefficients. The influence of B-site substitution on both coefficients was not substantial. The oxygen permeation flux of LSF, LSFTi2, and LSFTa1 was measured under air/argon gradient on planar membranes. The permeation rates of the membranes with thicknesses close to 1 mm were considered to be limited by surface exchange kinetics at temperatures above 875°C. The permeation rate of LSF was decreased (from 0.2 µmolcm-2s-1) to its third by Ti and Ta additions. The permeation rate of Ti and Ta-substituted samples showed a drop around 875°C, keeping a similar activation energy at lower and higher temperature regions. Oxygen vacancy ordering in the perovskite structure was given as a possible explanation, which provided explanation for the slow equilibrium in the lower temperature region. Tubular membranes of LSF and LSFTi2 (0.47 mm and 0.36 mm thick, respectively) and a planar LSFTa1 membrane were characterized using an air/(Ar-CH4) gradient. The measurements conducted using pure Ar on the lean-side provided the possibility to compare the thickness dependence of the permeation. In agreement with the previous observations, the permeation of the materials at and above 900°C was independent of the thickness, therefore, surface exchange limited. Stability under reducing atmospheres was increased by substitution. The LSF membrane failed shortly after the introduction of CH4 to the system, while LSFTi2 survived 5% CH4 and its oxygen permeation was improved substantially by a factor of 14. LSFTa1 membrane was measured with pure CH4 and the permeation was increased by a factor of 9, reaching 0.7 µmolcm-2s-1 at 900°C. The membrane operated stably over 2000h with pure CH4, 1000h. A slow degradation of 3.7% per 1000h was observed at 1000°C, most probably due to cation migration. The compositions identified as a result of B-site substitution screening were effective in improving the stability of the materials without extensive loss of the oxygen permeation rate. Ta-substituted material was shown to be promising with its long-term stability as a partial oxidation membrane.

EPFL2008

Solar Energy Stored as Hydrogen

Jérémie Minh-Châu Brillet

The tandem photoelectochemical (PEC) cell based on oxide semiconductors for water splitting offers a potentially inexpensive route for solar hydrogen generation. At the heart of the device, a nanostructured photoanode for water oxidation is connected in series with one or two dye-sensitized solar cells (DSCs) that provide an extra bias to photogenerated electrons in order to perform water reduction at the platinum cathode. In Part A of this thesis, after reviewing the different technologies available for solar hydrogen production, I focus on different possible architectures for photoanode / DSC tandem cells enabled by the most recent advances in the field. First, the development of all organic squaraine dyes having a narrow absorption bandwidth extending into the near infrared region and a broad transparent window in the visible region of the spectrum have allowed the design of a new photoanode / DSC / DSC tandem architecture. The "Back DSC" tandem cell, where two DSCs placed side-byside exploit the photons transmitted by a single photoanode is the conventional architecture. In this thesis, I demonstrate the inverted "Front DSC" architecture, which allows the use of non-transparent lower cost metallic substrate for the photoanode, as well as the "tri-level" tandem cell where a panchromatic "black" dyebased DSC exploits the energy transmitted by the photoanode and the squaraine dyebased DSC. Opto-electronic studies on each of these three architecture are performed and the respective solar-to-hydrogen conversion (STH) efficiencies of 1.16 %STH, 0.76 %STH and 1.36 %STH are assessed. Finally, I leverage recent findings in the field of high voltage DSCs to demonstrate for the first time a tandem cell using only one photovoltaic cell to perform complete water splitting at efficiencies as high as 3.10 % STH. Such a result represents a ten-fold improvement over previous demonstrations with this class of device. This work describes a breakthrough in the inexpensive solar-to-chemical conversion using improved photon management in a dual-absorber tandem cell and undoubtedly constitutes a benchmark for solar fuel production by solution processable oxide-based devices. In Part B, I focus on the photoanode for the oxygen evolution reaction. Hematite (α-Fe2O3) is a great candidate material for this application due to its availability, low cost, non-toxicity and appropriate band gap allowing extensive absorption in the visible part of the spectrum. However, it suffers severe drawbacks, among which are poor majority carrier conductivity and a short diffusion length of minority charge carrier with regard to photon penetration depth. This circumstance causes most photogenerated charges to have a low probability of reaching the semiconductor / liquid junction and thus to participate in the water oxidation reaction. This feature implies the use of hematite morphologies having feature size in the range of 10-20 nm. A solution-based colloidal approach offers a simple and easily scalable method to obtain nanostructured hematite. However, this type of nanostructure needs to be exposed to an annealing step at 800 °C to become photoactive. This has been attributed to the diffusion of dopants from the substrate. In addition, this annealing step sinters the 10 nm particles colloid into a feature size approaching 100 nm. Here, I first show the effect of intentionally doping this material on the sintering and photoactivity. I then demonstrate a method that allows for the first time to apply high temperature annealing steps while controlling the feature size of the nanoparticles. Such an approach can be applied to any kind of nanostructure. This latter strategy coupled to further passivation of surface states allowed an improvement of the net photoactivity of this type of photoanode by a factor of two. A reproducible net photocurrent exceeding 4 mA.cm-2 was obtained. This result represents the highest performance reported for hematite under one sun illumination. In Part C of this thesis, I present several synthesis methods for titania nanostructures acting as photoanodes in the DSC. In this photovoltaic cell, the electronic loss that is typically discussed is the slow transport induced recombination. Charges recombining before reaching the electrode have a detrimental influence on the photocurrent and photovoltage. Several approaches have been proposed in order to reduce interfacial recombination and improve charge collection in liquid electrolyte and solid state-DSCs (ss-DSCs) including the use of radial collection nanostructures, one-dimensional ZnO and TiO2 nanorods, and nanowires as photoanodes. Even though these approaches show great promise, they have yet to achieve power conversion efficiencies above 5% in liquid electrolyte DSCs and 1.7% in ss-DSCs. In this part of my thesis, I expose results on the strategies I have pursued during the course of my PhD to improve the dynamics in the liquid and ss-DSC. From one dimensional titania nanotube arrays, I have moved to tri-dimensional fibrous network of crystalline TiO2 and more complex host-passivation-guest photoelectrodes.

EPFL2012

Naphthalenediimide/Formamidinium-Based Low-Dimensional Perovskites

Paramvir Ahlawat, Masaud Hassan S Almalki, Vincent Henri Guillaume Dufoulon, David Lyndon Emsley, George Cameron Fish, Michael Graetzel, Farzaneh Jahanbakhshi, Dominik Józef Kubicki, Jovana Milic, Aditya Mishra, Marko Mladenovic, Jacques-Edouard Moser, Ursula Röthlisberger, Marco Alejandro Ruiz Preciado, Thomas Schneeberger, Pascal Alexander Schouwink, Shaik Mohammed Zakeeruddin

Low-dimensional hybrid perovskites have emerged as promising materials for optoelectronic applications. Although these materials have already demonstrated enhanced stability as compared to their three-dimensional perovskite analogues, their functionality has been limited by the insulating character of the organic moieties that primarily play a structure-directing role. This is particularly the case for the layered (2D) perovskite materials based on formamidinium lead iodide (FAPbI3) that remain scarce. We demonstrate a low-dimensional hybrid perovskite material based on a SPbI4 composition incorporating an electroactive naphthalenediimide (NDI) moiety as an organic spacer (S) between the perovskite slabs and evidence the propensity of the spacer to stabilize the α-FAPbI3 perovskite phase in hybrid low-dimensional SFAn–1PbnI3n+1 perovskite compositions. This has been investigated by means of solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy in conjunction with molecular dynamics simulations and density functional theory calculations. Theoretical calculations suggest an electronic contribution of the organic spacer to the resulting optoelectronic properties, which was confirmed by transient absorption spectroscopy. We have further analyzed these materials by time-resolved microwave conductivity measurements, revealing challenges for their application in photovoltaics.