Oxygen evolution reaction catalyzed by first-row transition metal oxides: stability and mechanism

Water splitting offers the opportunity for storing solar energy and, thus, producing carbon-neutral and renewable solar fuels. The process, known as artificial photosynthesis, is limited by the electrocatalytic conversion of water into molecular oxygen. Electrocatalysts are essential for reducing energy losses and improving the efficiency of the oxygen evolution reaction. This thesis describes the catalytic properties of first-row transition metal oxides for the OER and provides new insights into the mechanism of the reaction. Decades of research have yielded various transition metal oxides as efficient electrocatalysts for the OER, yet their stability is not well established. Here, a combination of techniques was employed to investigate the stability of unary, and mixed metal oxides; electrochemical activity measurements, electrochemical quartz crystal microbalance, inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometry and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy. The change of mass, composition, and activity metrics over time resolved the stability profiles of CoOx, CoFeOx, CoFeNiOx, NiOx, and NiFeOx. According to ICP-OES, the composition of all the five catalysts changed over time, while the CoOx and CoFeOx exhibited the most significant mass loss during an initial period of electrolysis. During a dynamic exchange of metal ions between the catalyst and the electrolyte, cobalt ions dissolve into the electrolyte, and iron from the electrolytic solution incorporates into the catalytic film. Once this dynamic exchange reaches equilibrium, the catalysts are stable. The mechanism of the OER mediated by amorphous cobalt oxyhydroxide was investigated by in situ spectroscopic and electrokinetic experiments. In situ surface-enhanced Raman and X-ray absorption spectroscopy supported a Co(IV)-O species at potentials before the onset of OER. The gradual transformation of the catalyst into a CoO2 concurred with the appearance of a superoxidic species. In situ SERS coupled with 18O and H/D isotope experiments provided evidence for the participation of the superoxidic species in the oxygen evolution reaction. The catalyst exhibits a Tafel slope of 60 mV/dec, a first-order dependence of the catalytic activity, and a proton-coupled electron-transfer pre-equilibrium. These findings propose a new OER mechanism, in which the rate-determining step is the release of oxygen from a Co-superoxo intermediate. Iron incorporation into the cobalt lattice enhances the catalytic activity greatly. Even though there are several studies on the OER mechanism in Co-Fe oxides, many vital questions on the role of iron, the true nature of active sites, and the oxidation states of Co and Fe remain. In situ SERS and XAS indicated the presence of Co(IV)-O species and a Fe valency higher than three at potentials prior to the oxygen evolution. An O-O- band, attributed to the superoxidic species, emerged at potentials lower than the onset of OER. In situ SERS coupled with 18O isotope experiments confirmed that both the lattice oxygen and superoxidic species participate in the oxygen evolution. The Tafel slope is about 37 mV/dec indicating that both the pre-equilibrium and rate-determining step involve a single-electron transfer. These findings support that neither the Co(III)/Co(IV) oxidation nor the O-O bond formation are controlling the rate of the reaction.

Nanostructured Electrocatalysts for Water Splitting Reactions

Lucas-Alexandre Stern

At the dawn of the 21st century, mankind is facing an important energy challenge. Future energy demand can only be met by large scale exploitation of renewable energy resources. Solar energy is abundant, with a sufficient capacity for the growing energy demand. However, it is necessary to implement renewable energy storage means. Hydrogen is considered as the energy carrier of the future. An energy economy based on hydrogen is viable only if hydrogen is produced from sustainable means. Water electrolysis is the most promising technique to produce hydrogen directly from water. Yet, the efficiency is limited and electrocatalysts are required to drive both the hydrogen evolution reaction and oxygen evolution reaction. Scarce and expensive materials are currently used to drive these reactions. It is, thus, imperative that efficient Earth-abundant catalysts are developed. Nanostructuring enhances the performance of inexpensive materials for water splitting and several catalysts were studied for this goal. Chapter 2 describes the application of nanostructuring technique to the archetypical catalysts that are nickel oxides for oxygen evolution. The prepared nanoparticles show superior activity towards oxygen evolution than that of their bulk counterpart. The ultrafine size of nanoparticles synthesized allowed the exposure of a higher number of active sites. The activity for oxygen evolution was, thus, significantly enhanced. We also detailed that short conditioning of the electrode improved the performance of the evaluated materials. In chapter 3 we carefully studied nanoparticles and nanowires of nickel phosphide. The catalysts is known to be really active for hydrogen evolution. Our group suspected that this material was, also, a potential oxygen evolution catalyst. We proved, for the first time, that nickel phosphide is a remarkable oxygen evolution catalyst. Under alkaline conditions, used for oxygen evolution, we observed an in-situ formation of a core-shell heterostructure, a typical nanostructure architecture. The surface oxidation of this material allowed high oxygen evolution capabilities. We concluded that careful oxidation of nanostructured materials, as observed for nickel phosphide, is essential for the preparation of future outstanding oxygen evolution catalysts. Chapter 4 details the fabrication of direct solar-to-fuel electrode using cobalt phosphide as hydrogen evolving catalyst. Instead of using the electrical energy provided by solar energy, solar irradiation on the developed assembly allows direct hydrogen production. The careful design of the light-sensitive electrode (photocathode) is detailed. Simple incorporation of cobalt phosphide by means of photodeposition alleviates the cost of the electrode fabrication. The assembled electrode is active for hydrogen evolution under visible light irradiation. In the chapter 5 we sought to fabricate a 3-dimensional hydrogen evolving catalyst. This nanostructure is based on polymer brushes on a flat conducting substrate. Once the brushes are grown on the substrate, a molybdenum sulfide catalyst is then incorporated by simple soaking technique. We were able to tune the loading of the catalyst and the corresponding activity by changing the polymer properties. The height of the polymer was modified as well as its packing density. The resulting activity proved superior to similar approaches and to previous reports on carefully engineered molybdenum sulfide catalysts.

EPFL2017

Coupling of electrocatalysts to photoabsorbers for solar fuels production

Carlos Gilberto Morales Guio

The direct transformation of sunlight into fuels and chemicals has attracted considerable attention for the potential impact on the storage of solar energies at large scales and the reduction of CO2 emissions. More than 80% of our current global energy consumption comes from the burning of non-renewable fossil fuels which produces enormous quantities of CO2 and contributes to global warming. We believe today that the key to reduce our dependence on exhaustible natural resources and limit the emission of greenhouse gases is the transition to CO2-free renewable energy sources. However, harvesting of energy from renewable sources (i.e. solar, wind, tidal) is intermittent and the deployment of devices for their transformation into useful forms of energy (i.e. electricity, chemicals, fuels, biomass) in a global scale is conditioned upon the improvement in efficiency of the energy storage mechanisms. A promising approach to store energy is the use of sunlight to drive the production of hydrogen fuel from water. Hydrogen produced from water and sunlight can be transformed back to electricity on demand or be used to generate mechanical energy in cars to power the transportation industry. The oxidation of hydrogen generates useable energy and at the same time exhaust clean, carbon-free water as the only product. Therefore, the production of hydrogen using a renewable energy source in an efficient and inexpensive device has the potential to discourage the continued use of fossil fuels and improve our environment. The viability of any mechanism for the storage of sunlight as fuel will depend on the reduction of energy penalties during the transformation process. Electrocatalysts are advanced materials that bring into one active site electrons and molecules in the appropriate orientation to lower activation energy barriers, accelerate rate of transformations and improve overall efficiencies for chemical reactions. The best catalysts for water splitting are precious metals such as Pt, Ir and Ru, which show superior rates of reaction at low overpotentials. However, these noble metals are too expensive and scarce for large scale applications. This thesis summarizes our recent research in the preparation, characterization, and application of Earth-abundant electrocatalysts for solar water splitting. Although in the last decade a great number of efficient and inexpensive electrocatalysts have been reported, methods for the deposition of these materials on the surface of photoabsorbers are rarely reported. This work shows various simple and scalable techniques for the deposition of hydrogen and oxygen evolving electrocatalysts on the surface of photocathodes and photoanodes, respectively. Surface-protected photocahodes were activated for solar hydrogen production in alkaline conditions with MoS2+x, Ni-Mo and Mo2C. A novel method for the deposition of an optically transparent amorphous iron nickel oxide oxygen evolution electrocatalyst is also reported. The catalyst was deposited on both thin film and high-aspect ratio nanostructured hematite photoanodes. The low catalyst loading combined with its high activity at low overpotential results in significant improvement on the onset potential for photoelectrochemical water oxidation. This transparent catalyst further enables the preparation of a stable hematite/perovskite solar cell tandem device, which performs unassisted water splitting.

EPFL2016

Study of N2O decomposition over Fe-ZSM-5 with transient methods

Petra Prechtl

Nitrous oxide is the third most important gas contributing to global warming and its concentration in the atmosphere is still on the rise. Nitric acid production represents the largest source of N2O in the chemical industry, with a total annual emission of about 400 kt N2O. An efficient way to reduce the N2O is the catalytic decomposition into N2 and O2. ZSM-5 zeolites containing iron are known to be effective in this reaction involving Fe(II)-extraframework species as active sites. But the nature of these sites and the reaction network is still under debate. Often the N2O is in the exhaust together with other gases like NOx, COx, oxygen, and water vapor, which may influence the catalyst efficiency towards N2O decomposition. The effect of these gases on the reaction mechanism is still not understood yet. The aim of this work is to study the decomposition mechanism of N2O over isomorphously substituted Fe-ZSM-5 (0.02-0.55% Fe) using transient response methods. Kinetic studies under steady-state conditions give overall information about the reaction, whereas transient experiments lead to information on the individual steps and the possibility to suggest a reaction model. Transient response methods are applied in vacuum using a Temporal Analysis of Products (TAP) setup and at ambient pressure using a Micromeritics AutoChem 2910 analyzer. The influence of different gases such as NO, H2O and NO2 on the decomposition of N2O over Fe-ZSM-5 is investigated to gain insight into their effect on this reaction. The TAP multifunctional reactor system is used to perform transient pulse experiments for micro-kinetic analysis of complex heterogeneous catalytic reactions. This setup allows to dose precisely reactants and to monitor product formation with submillisecond time resolution implying the absence of external mass or heat transfer. A reproducible low hydroxylation level of the catalyst can be attained in vacuum. The results from the transient responses with the Micromeritics analyzer are obtained under conditions more relevant to "operando". The mechanism of N2O decomposition over Fe containing ZSM-5 was studied by transient response methods at ambient pressure with the Micromeritics analyzer and under vacuum with the TAP setup. Both approaches showed that the mechanism strongly depends on the reaction temperature, but in all cases involves atomic oxygen loading from N2O with N2 evolution as the first reaction step. The surface oxygen, (O)Fe, formed from N2O possesses very high reactivity and oxidizes CO to CO2 already at 373 K. A complete saturation of the active sites can be reached by the catalyst exposure to N2O at low temperatures (T < 600 K in vacuum, T < 523 K at ambient pressure). Under these conditions oxygen is stored and does not desorb. On that basis, the concentration of sites active for the surface atomic oxygen loading from N2O is determined by pulse experiments using the TAP setup. The concentration of active sites is found to be the same as in a flow experiment with the Micromeritics analyzer. The mechanism of surface atomic oxygen recombination and desorption as O2 depends on the temperature. At temperatures higher than 773 K, the mechanism probably involves direct (O)Fe recombination. The investigation of the response profiles upon N2O pulses at 803 K evidences the O2 formation is the rate-determining step since the oxygen desorption is found to be slow compared to N2O and N2. Furthermore, a fit of the oxygen desorption curve corresponded to a first order dependence on the oxygen surface coverage. In the range of 523 to 773 K, the O2 formation is facilitated by NO, which is formed on the catalyst surface from N2O. The addition of NO to the gas phase confirmed the accelerating effect of NO on the oxygen desorption. NO and (O)Fe are adsorbed on adjacent, but different sites and are not competing for the same ones. Adsorbed NO accommodates oxygen from N2O forming higher oxidized nitrogen oxide species NO2/NO3 which decompose back to NOads and molecular oxygen. Thus, the recombination of surface oxygen loaded from N2O is accelerated by a NO/NOx redox cycle whereas adsorbed NOx acts as co-catalyst. Adsorbed NO is oxidized by N2O easily as shown also by temperature-programmed desorption (TPD) experiments. Therefore, the interaction of gaseous NO2 with Fe-ZSM-5 at 523 K in vacuum and at ambient pressure is investigated and demonstrates the formation of two different NOx surface species accompanied by the evolution of gaseous NO. These surface species block the sites for oxygen loading from N2O whereas the amount of reversible adsorbed N2O stays constant compared to the standard pre-treated catalyst. The formation of reactive surface oxygen from NO2 could neither be evidenced in TPD nor with CO oxidation experiments. Adsorbed water strongly influences the N2O decomposition inhibiting it completely, at least at temperatures ≤ 673 K. Water pulses at 523 and 593 K result in partial desorption of the loaded atomic surface oxygen as O2, indicating the competition of water for the same adsorption sites. The residual adsorbed oxygen desorbs during TPD experiments at 849 K instead of 715 K for the dry catalyst and it can not oxidize CO to CO2. It means that the active sites are transformed into an inactive form in the presence of water. The oxygen which stays on the catalyst seems to participate in the Fe(II) oxidation to the hydroxylated Fe(III) species. These Fe(III) species are inactive in N2O decomposition and could be activated again by high temperature treatment in He or in vacuum. During TAP experiments only small amounts of water are dosed and the water desorption is facilitated due to vacuum. Therefore, the effect of water could be shown to be reversible at temperatures > 700 K. At 803 K oxygen desorbs significantly faster with increasing water amount suggesting a water assisted O2 desorption. Simultaneously, the catalyst activity decreases to about a half of the initial activity of the dry zeolite. To conclude, from the TAP reactor data obtained under vacuum conditions and the results from the transient flow experiments at ambient pressure it follows that the mechanism of the N2O decomposition over Fe-containing ZSM-5 depends strongly on the reaction temperature and on the presence of NO, H2O and NO2. In general, below 523 K only surface atomic oxygen loading from N2O takes place with simultaneous evolution of N2 in the gas phase. The O2 formation proceeds via direct (O)Fe recombination at temperatures above 773 K. In the range of 523 to 773 K, the recombination of the atomic oxygen involves NOx adsorbed on the catalyst surface.

EPFL2007