Durability of structural adhesives in bridges

Besides the 50s revolution of the use of adhesives in the new construction in the works of strengthening and repair of different structural elements, adhesives were extensively used in bridges for a long time. Different applications on bridges were carried out in the last few decades. The most common application of adhesives in bridge engineering was in the form of resin mortar for either bridge bearings or expansion joint nosings. Recently more applications of structural, semi-structural and non structural joints could be executed using adhesives in bridges. In reason of its ease of execution and maintenance as well as its long-term durability, resins represent highly challenging materials in last few decades for the means of formulating bridge connections. Although adhesives are recently used on wide ranges in joints in bridge engineering, their complicated behaviour, particularly under low temperatures, could disallow an easier use of such materials in structures, notably in bridges. As the following project targets to provide a better understanding of thermo-mechanical behaviour of resins, two different categories of testing were carried out, in order to investigate the most important and basic characteristics of resins as well as direct relations connecting different properties. The first series of tests was focusing on the physical characterization of resins aiming to investigate the influence of the degree of cure (conversion degree) on different characteristics as well as the behaviour of the material, From previous experiences on the behaviour of resins, it was expected that the more cured the material, the better properties it could present, however this investigation was held in LTC lab using a DSC machine. Different categories of tests were carried out during the physical characterization in order to establish a reliable relation between conversion degree/conversion rate and time. Another effective resin property that was considered during the physical characterization of resins is the glass transition temperature (Tg); Tg which represents the temperature at which the material loses part of its strength and/or stiffness, can also involve another concern which is the degradation of adhesives when exposed to high temperatures. The second series of testing involved in this project is mechanical testing, which was held in Lab of structures. This series was aiming to investigate the mechanical properties of the resin, basically compressive, tensile and shear strengths of these materials. Finally this project was focusing on relating the physical properties including mainly the degree of cure as well as the glass transition temperature to the mechanical properties and their influence on the mechanical behaviour of adhesives.

Material and structural performance of fiber-reinforced polymer composites at elevated and high temperatures

As the range of applications for fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composite materials in civil engineering constantly increases, there is more and more concern with regard to their performance in critical environments. The fire behavior of composite materials is especially important since complex physical and chemical processes such as the glass transition and decomposition occur when these materials are subjected to elevated and high temperatures, possibly leading to considerable loss of stiffness and strength. This stiffness and strength degradation in composite materials under elevated and high temperatures is the result of changes in polymer molecular structures. When polyester thermosets are subjected to elevated and high temperatures, they undergo three transitions (glass transition, leathery-to-rubbery transition, and rubbery-to-decomposed transition), corresponding to four different states (glassy, leathery, rubbery and decomposed). At a certain temperature, a composite material can therefore be considered as a mixture of materials that are in different states. As the content of each state varies with temperature, the composite material exhibits temperature-dependent properties. Since these changes in state can be described using kinetic theory, the quantity of material in each state can be estimated and the thermophysical and thermomechanical properties of the mixture can thus be determined. These concepts formed a basis for the development of thermophysical and thermomechanical property sub-models for composites at elevated and high temperatures and even for the description of post-fire status. Incorporating these thermophysical property sub-models into a heat transfer governing equation, thermal responses were calculated using a finite difference method. Integrating the thermomechanical property sub-models within structural theory, the mechanical responses were described using a finite element method and the time-to-failure was also predicted by defining a failure criterion. The modeling results for temperature responses, mechanical responses and post-fire behavior were compared with those obtained from structural endurance experiments on full-scale cellular GFRP (glass fiber-reinforced polymer, in this case polyester resin) panels subjected to a four-point bending configuration and fire from one side. The modeling results for time-to-failure were compared with those from the experiments carried out on GFRP tubes under combined compressive and thermal loadings. In each experimental setup, two different thermal boundary conditions were investigated – with and without water cooling through specimen cells – and good agreement was found. The understanding gained and modeling of the behavior of GFRP composites under elevated and high temperatures carried out in this thesis could be applicable for different composite materials, and also benefit investigations regarding both active and passive fire protection techniques in order to improve the fire resistance of structures made of such materials.

EPFL2009

Thermophysical and Thermomechanical Behavior of Cold-Curing Structural Adhesives in Bridge Construction

Omar Moussa

The use of the structural adhesive bonding technique is well established in the aircraft and automotive industries where, in most cases, joints can be fabricated indoors under controlled conditions. In the civil engineering domain, however, load-bearing structures are normally erected on-site in outdoor conditions, i.e. joint fabrication is exposed to varying outdoor temperature and humidity profiles and particularly in winter, when long periods of very low temperatures are frequent, the on-site joining of structural components must remain possible. Consequently, and due to the generally large scale of the structural components, cold-curing adhesives are used, unlike in other fields where hot-curing adhesives are used. Although it offers many potential advantages in bridge construction, structural adhesive bonding is not yet widely used in civil engineering structures. This can be attributed, amongst other things, to the lack of knowledge regarding adhesive behavior during exposure to varying environmental conditions. Despite significant research efforts concerning the characterization of structural adhesives, the question of the changes that occur in the thermophysical and thermomechanical properties of cold-curing structural adhesives during their service life, and particularly at early age and low temperatures, is yet to be addressed. The objective of this work was therefore, based on experimental and analytical investigations, to understand the thermophysical and thermomechanical behavior of cold-curing structural adhesives from the time of the mixing of the different components and throughout the long-term service life. Investigations of curing at early age and low temperatures (during winter) showed that curing already takes place at temperatures slightly above 0 °C. The process is very slow however and several days of curing are required to attain significant curing degrees. The glass transition temperature, Tg, develops even more slowly due to early initiation of vitrification. A new and practical experimental method was developed to establish the relationship between glass transition temperature and curing degree for different types of cold-curing adhesives. Furthermore, cure kinetics (developed for hot-curing adhesives) proved its applicability for cold-curing adhesives at low temperatures. In contrast to thermophysical properties, mechanical properties start developing significantly only after the onset of material vitrification. Lower curing temperatures also significantly decelerate the development process. An empirical model to predict strength and stiffness as a function of simple or complex curing temperature profiles particularly for curing at low temperatures was developed, taking the temperature-dependent vitrification into account. During summer, the temperature at specific locations of certain joints (e.g. joints below the asphalt) may exceed Tg, which may lead to a significant drop in mechanical properties. The investigations showed that when cooled to temperatures below Tg, the mechanical properties fully recovered and even a significant increase in properties is achieved due to post-curing. An existing model to predict temperature-dependent mechanical properties was extended to predict the change in stiffness and strength resulting from the exceeding of Tg and subsequently after recovery. Over the long term and during ambient curing, a significant increase in mechanical and thermophysical properties occurs over the years and decades due to the completion of curing. A model based on the similar long-term increase of concrete properties was revised to also predict the long-term strength and stiffness of cold-curing structural adhesives. Finally several case studies demonstrate how the outcome of this research can be applied, particularly to predict mechanical properties at early age and low temperatures. Such results can be used to plan construction stages or estimate the required waiting periods prior to a bridge being brought into service.

EPFL2011

Time dependence of material properties of FRP composites in fire

Thomas Keller

Temperature dependence of physical and mechanical properties is considered in most thermal and mechanical response models for composite materials. Based on thermogravimetry analysis, differential scanning calorimetry, and dynamic mechanical analysis conducted at different heating rates, it is demonstrated that thermophysical and thermomechanical properties are not univariate functions of temperature, but also functions of time. Temperature- and time-dependent models for physical and mechanical properties at elevated and high temperatures are proposed, which show good accordance with experimental results. Based on a finite difference method, complex realistic thermal loading programs such as the ISO fire curve can be taken into account. © 2009 SAGE Publications

2009

Material and structural performance of fiber-reinforced polymer composites at elevated and high temperatures

EPFL2009

Thermophysical and Thermomechanical Behavior of Cold-Curing Structural Adhesives in Bridge Construction

Omar Moussa

EPFL2011