Mapping Catalyst‐Solvent Interplay in Competing Carboamination/Cyclopropanation Reactions

Group 9 metals, in particular Rh III complexes with cyclopentadienyl ligands, are competent C–H activation catalysts. Recently, a CpRh III catalyzed reaction of alkenes with N -enoxyphthalimides showed divergent outcome based on the solvent, with carboamination favored in methanol and cyclopropanation in 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol (TFE). Here, we create selectivity and activity maps capable of unravelling the catalyst-solvent interplay on the outcome of these competing reactions by analyzing 42 cyclopentadienyl metal catalysts, Cp X M III (M = Co, Rh, Ir). These maps not only can be used to rationalize previously reported experimental results, but also capably predict the behavior of untested catalyst/solvent combinations as well as aid in identifying experimental protocols that simultaneously optimize both catalytic activity and selectivity (solutions in the Pareto front). In this regard, we demonstrate how and why the experimentally employed CpRh III catalyst represents an ideal choice to invoke a solvent-induced change in reactivity. Additionally, the maps reveal the degree to which even perceived minor changes in the solvent ( e.g. , replacing methanol with ethanol) influence the ratio of carboamination and cyclopropanation products. Overall, the selectivity and activity maps presented here provide a generalizable tool to create global pictures of anticipated reaction outcome that can be used to develop new experimental protocols spanning metal, ligand, and solvent space.

Chemical and electrochemical promotion of supported rhodium catalyst

Olena Baranova

The chemical and electrochemical promotion of highly dispersed nanofilm Rh catalysts (dispersion: about 10 %, film thickness: 40 nm) has been investigated for the first time. To this end Rh metal was sputter-deposited, either on a purely ionic conductor (8 % Y2O3-stabilized ZrO2) or on a mixed ionic-electronic conductor (TiO2), the latter being a highly dispersed layer of TiO2 (4 µm) deposited on YSZ. These catalysts are designated as Rh/YSZ and Rh/TiO2/YSZ, respectively. It was established analytically that both in the Rh/YSZ and in the Rh/TiO2/YSZ system, the catalyst films have a nanoparticle-size grain structure. The Rh supported on titania is rather porous, exhibiting a higher dispersion and surface area than Rh on YSZ. Both after reduction (H2, T=400 °C) and after oxidation (O2, T=400 °C), Rh supported on TiO2 was found to be in a more highly reduced state than Rh on YSZ. After reducing treatment, the Rh/TiO2/YSZ samples contain a larger amount of weakly bonded oxygen, which can be attributed to oxygen "backspillover" from the TiO2. A major feature of this research was the electrochemical characterization of the oxygen/Rh/solid electrolyte three-phase boundary by steady-state polarization measurements and by impedance spectroscopy. These are powerful techniques for extracting experimental trends and details that are useful for an understanding of the electrochemical promotion principles. It was shown that the exchange current densities at the Rh/solid electrolyte interface are lower on account of the TiO2 layer. The exchange current densities are more than twice lower at Rh/TiO2(4 µm)/YSZ than at Rh/YSZ, demonstrating that the former interface is much more polarizable. The mechanism of oxygen exchange occurring close to equilibrium (O2/O2- couple) was investigated for the first time at Rh catalyst electrodes interfaced with solid electrolyte. The processes of cathodic oxygen reduction and anodic oxygen evolution are not symmetric, but they are similar in the two systems, Rh/YSZ and Rh/TiO2(4 µm)/YSZ. The cathodic process consists of three steps: dissociative adsorption of oxygen at the gas-exposed Rh surface, atomic oxygen diffusion to the electrochemical reaction sites (ERS), and a two-electron transfer to this oxygen on the ERS. The cathodic process is limited by interfacial diffusion of oxygen atoms from the gas-exposed metal surface to the ERS. The anodic process includes two steps: two-electron transfer reaction, which is the rate-determining step, and oxygen desorption to the gas phase. With data obtained from impedance spectroscopy at the equilibrium potential, it was possible to confirm the reaction scheme proposed. It was demonstrated that Rh nanofilm catalysts interfaced with YSZ or TiO2/YSZ can be electrochemically promoted for the reaction of ethylene oxidation. Small anodic currents cause periodic oscillations in catalytic rate and potential of the Rh/YSZ catalyst, while at Rh/TiO2/YSZ they give rise to a stable and reversible rate enhancement by up to a factor 80. The increase in ethylene oxidation rate is up to 2000 times larger than the electrochemical rate, I/2F, of O2- oxidation. The pronounced electrochemical promotion behavior that has been observed is due to the anodically controlled migration of O2- species from the electrolyte to the Rh/gas interface. At the Rh surface, these species destabilize the formation of rhodium surface oxide (Rh2O3). The existence of backspillover oxygen species has been confirmed by impedance measurements under positive applied potential. Another significant result for heterogeneous catalysis is the finding that thick as well as thin films of Rh/TiO2/YSZ catalyst are open to chemical promotion of ethylene oxidation and partial methane oxidation, ie, they offer a higher catalytic activity and stability than the Rh/YSZ catalysts. The modification of catalytic activity observed for Rh/TiO2/YSZ was attributed to either a "long-range" electronic-type SMSI mechanism or to a self-driven electrochemical promotion mechanism. In both cases, the ultimate cause of promotion are different work functions of catalyst and support. Equilibration of the work functions of two solids in contact induces surface charging, a migration of O2- ions to the catalyst/gas interface, and a weakening of the Rh-O chemisorptive bonds. It facilitates reduction of oxidized surface sites. Another important achievement of the present work was that of exploring and confirming the possibilities of current-assisted activation of Rh/TiO2/YSZ catalysts. In partial methane oxidation using close to stoichiometric gas compositions (CH4 : O2 = 2 : 1) at 550 °C, the inactive (oxidized) Rh/TiO2/YSZ catalyst was successfully activated by applied currents, either positive or negative. This phenomenon is an example of "permanent" electrochemical promotion furnishing a permanent rate enhancement ratio of γ = 11. The activation by negative currents is explained in terms of an electrochemical reduction of rhodium surface oxide, while the activation by positive currents can be explained by the mechanism of electrochemical promotion.

EPFL2005

Production d'hydrogène dans un réacteur microstructuré

Pierre Reuse

The aim of this work was to operate the steam reforming of methanol and the total oxidation of methanol in a microstructured two-passage reactor. The steam reforming enables the production of hydrogen at relatively low temperatures (250 °C) with only a small amount of carbon monoxide (~ 1%). After a cleaning step (CO preferential oxidation, for example), this hydrogen would be a good feed for a fuel cell to produce electricity for mobile applications. Steam reforming is an endothermic reaction. The energy needed to run this reaction is produced by the total oxidation, a strongly exothermic reaction. To allow an efficient heat transfer between these two reactions, a microstructured reactor was used. These structures, with dimensions in the micron range, are widely known to have far better heat transfer capacity than traditional heat exchangers. Furthermore, these structures have some unique features with respect to classical reactors. A narrow residence time distribution, close to that of a plug flow reactor, can be obtained, keeping selectivity high for complex reactions. Microstructured reactors also have small residence time, allowing very quick variations in the feed and experimental conditions. In chapter 4, the concepts relating to the channel coatings will be presented. A Cu/Zn/Al catalyst provided by Süd-Chemie was transformed into a suspension of nanoparticles in isopropanol by using an attrition grinding apparatus. A thin layer (~5 µm) of catalyst was formed on the microchannel walls. Several tests were performed to characterize the adhesion of this layer. The influence of the layer on the residence time distribution was also investigated; it was possible to maintain Bodenstein numbers as high as 50. Chapter 5 is focused on the steam reforming of methanol, the reaction that generates hydrogen. A kinetic analysis in differential and integral modes established that the rate of the reaction is inhibited by hydrogen, the main product of the reaction; the partial order is - 0.2. The influence of water on the rate of reaction is negligible (partial order of 0.1), and methanol has a positive partial order of 0.7. A kinetic constant of 5.57 · 10-6 mol0.4 · (m3)0.6 · gcat-1 · s-1 at 200 °C and an activation energy of 73.9 kJ · mol-1 complete the description of the kinetics of the steam reforming. Throughout the comparisons, we showed that the catalyst coated in the microchannels has an initial rate for the steam reforming 30% higher than the original catalyst in fixed bed. We can therefore conclude that the catalyst modification procedure does not diminish the catalyst activity. This was also shown by comparing our results with results available in the scientific literature for similar catalysts. CO2 selectivity remains high and constant then decreases as 90% conversion is approached. Working with an excess of water with respect to methanol contributes to keeping the selectivity high. A molar ratio of 1.2 is a good compromise between selectivity and increased energy costs due to the vaporization of the additional water. It's also beneficial to work at conversions below 90% to be in the high selectivity domain and to diminish the inhibiting influence of hydrogen. Finally, we showed that this catalyst deactivates over 100 hours at a temperature of 300 °C. A kinetic model for the deactivation at temperatures between 300 °C and 330 °C was established. In chapter 6 the total oxidation of methanol was studied. A cobalt based catalyst was developed to allow the synchronization of the two reactions temperatures. The minimum temperature for complete conversion for the total oxidation reaction must clearly not exceed an acceptable working temperature for the steam reforming catalyst (i.e. a temperature that results in an acceptable catalyst lifetime). A kinetic analysis determined partial orders for methanol and oxygen as 0.67, the kinetic constant at 230 °C as 5.45 · 10-3 mmol-0.33 · m4 · (gcat · s)-1 and the activation energy as 130 kJ · mol-1. The copper based catalyst used for the steam reforming of methanol was also active for the total oxidation of methanol. Unfortunately the minimal temperature to ensure a total conversion was not compatible with the working temperature of the steam reforming. In chapter 7, the results concerning the coupling of the two previously studied reactions are presented. The numerous fittings and cables necessary for the operation of the reactor didn't allow the reactor to be run in an autothermal mode. Therefore constant, not regulated, heating was used to compensate the thermal losses. By coupling the two reactions and by studying the dynamic response time of the reactor (temperature and conversion of the steam reforming reaction) at the time of stopping and starting the oxidation reaction, we've seen that the temperature increase was around +10 °C within 60 seconds and that the conversion for the steam reforming of the methanol fitted well with the temperature increase. This reactor also has good dynamics and responds quickly to feed variations. When the coupling mode was changed from co-current to counter-current we noticed a significant increase in conversion. Furthermore, selectivity in counter-current mode remained high, even for conversion approaching 100%.

EPFL2003

Ruthenium vs. Osmium Complexes as Catalysts for Atom Transfer Radical Addition Reactions

Gregor Kiefer, Rosario Scopelliti, Kay Severin, Katrin Anne Thommes

The catalytic activity of [CpOsBr2(PPh3)] in conjunction with Mg has been evaluated for atom transfer radical addition (ATRA) and cyclization (ATRC) reactions. The Os complex enabled these reactions to be performed with similar efficiency as that of the analogous Ru complex [CpRuCl2(PPh3)]. The olefin complex [CpOsBr(H2C=CHPh)(PPh3)] was obtained by reduction of [CpOsBr2(PPh3)] with Mg in the presence of an excess of styrene, whereas an analogous Ru complex was not observed. Kinetic investigations suggest that olefin complexes of Os can form under catalytic conditions.